Skip to content
Likelier

Action vs. inaction: figure for each choice

Buying disability income insurance vs. going without

If you act

Buying disability income insurance

30%

If you don't

Going without disability income insurance

80%

At least one figure is an indirect estimate, not a measured regret rate. How each figure was built is shown below.


Financial

Last reviewed 2026-05-13

Evidence quality 4.38/5

Eight-dimension review score against the quality rubric . Each dimension scored 1–5.

D1 Source verification
5/5
D2 Source authority & independence
5/5
D3 Regret-rate accuracy
3/5
D4 Source comparability
2/5
D5 Gilovich pattern
5/5
D6 Prose quality
5/5
D7 Caveat completeness
5/5
D8 Sample quality
5/5
Average 4.38/5
A pay stub and an empty wallet side by side on a plain surface.
Indirect data: for this decision at least one figure comes from an indirect measure, such as outcomes, satisfaction or intent, or from an editorial estimate, rather than from a direct regret survey. The notes for each side below say how its figure was built.

If you act

Buying disability income insurance

30%

~30% of workers who dropped disability insurance say they weren't 'using the benefit enough to be worth it'

US employees who previously had workplace disability insurance and then dropped it

retrospective, cross-sectional

If you don't

Going without disability income insurance

80%

~80% of uninsured workers who experienced a disability leave report they have not fully recovered financially

US full-time workers who experienced a disability leave and had no disability insurance at the time

retrospective; surveyed within 10 years of disability leave

Figure for each choice (the measure is named on the page)

Related decisions

Semantically similar decisions — same territory, different trade-offs.

Financial

Long-term care insurance vs. self-insure

Figure for each choice (the measure is named on the page)

Financial

Hire a lawyer for an auto injury claim

Figure for each choice (the measure is named on the page)

FinancialDirect

Buying a house

% who regret this choice

Inaction dominates

Inaction regret 5.6× higher

Financial

Payday loan decision

Figure for each choice (the measure is named on the page)

Financial

Investing

Figure for each choice (the measure is named on the page)

Financial

Home renovation

Figure for each choice (the measure is named on the page)

career

Salary negotiation

Figure for each choice (the measure is named on the page)

career

Master's vs stop at bachelor's

Figure for each choice (the measure is named on the page)

Risks behind this decision

The probabilities that sit underneath this choice.

Workers who become disabled and lack income-replacement coverage face an abrupt income cliff. The Social Security Administration estimates that one in four of today’s 20-year-olds will experience a qualifying disability before reaching retirement age, yet LIMRA’s 2024 Insurance Barometer Study found fewer than one in five US adults carry any disability income insurance — a gap of roughly 51 million working adults. Guardian Life’s workplace benefits research found that among households that actually experienced a disability leave without coverage, 80% reported they had not fully recovered financially years later, compared with 38% financial harm among workers who held disability insurance during the same event. The asymmetry is large and consistent across data sources.

Regret among buyers is real but structurally different. Insurance economics research documents a “waste aversion” dynamic: Krishnan and Iyer (2022) show experimentally that the thought of having “wasted” premiums when no loss occurs causally reduces the coverage people buy. LIMRA data on lapsed policyholders quantifies the same sentiment — 30% of workers who dropped disability coverage cited “not using the benefit enough to be worth it” as their stated reason. These figures describe an expectation of wasted spending rather than harm; the policyholder who never became disabled is, by definition, the one who avoided the outcome the policy was designed for. Buyer regret is primarily about the cost of an unused option, not about a worse life outcome.

The two regret types are not symmetric. Inaction regret, when it materializes, arrives alongside job loss, depleted savings, and delayed retirement — harms that are concrete and long-lasting. Research published in the American Journal of Public Health found that medically related work loss contributed to over 44% of US personal bankruptcies in one analysis, and households with a disabled adult require substantially more income to maintain equivalent living standards. Action regret, by contrast, is largely anticipatory: most buyers never claim, pay premiums throughout their working years, and may retrospectively question the cost. The evidence does not suggest that buyers who purchased and never claimed experienced lasting harm from having done so. Inaction dominates the regret calculus when conditioned on the event the coverage is designed to address.

Sources: action

Claim ledger

Every number below is what each source reported, with the verbatim quote we relied on and how we arrived at our figure. Click any link to verify directly.

1/2 sources independently verified verbatim against the cited source

  1. [1] Economics Letters 2022;216:110594 / S. Sai Krishnan & Subramanian S. Iyer — Can waste aversion affect demand for insurance? Evidence from experiment and survey
    Can waste aversion affect demand for insurance? Evidence from experiment and survey
    Statistic
    Waste averters demand lower insurance coverage than non-waste averters — the discouraging thought of having 'wasted' premiums if no loss occurs reduces the amount of coverage people buy
    Excerpt
    “"Evidence shows that people are discouraged from buying fair insurance by the thought that if they do not suffer a loss, they will have wasted their money. We extend this theory to test if waste aversion could lead to a reduction in the amount of coverage sought. We deploy a multimethod design wherein we first run incentive-compatible experiments to establish a cause-and-effect relationship. We follow it up with a survey rolled out to actual buyers of insurance to generate external validity for our results. Our findings show that waste averters demand lesser insurance coverage than non-waste averters." ”
    Source data from
    2022-07-01
    Accessed
    2026-06-30
    Calculation
    Krishnan & Iyer (Economics Letters 2022;216:110594) establish, via incentive-compatible experiments plus a survey of actual insurance buyers, that "waste aversion" — anticipated regret over premiums paid without a claim — causally lowers the amount of coverage demanded. This source documents the MECHANISM behind buyer regret on the action side; it does not report a quantified regret rate (the action regret_rate is anchored on the LIMRA lapse figure below, not on this paper).
  2. [2] LIMRA — Disability Insurance Awareness Month: Is Your Income Protected? Verified
    Disability Insurance Awareness Month: Is Your Income Protected?
    Statistic
    30% of employees who dropped disability insurance cited 'not using the benefit enough to be worth it' as their reason
    Excerpt
    “"LIMRA research finds that employees who previously had coverage but dropped their disability insurance cited the following reasons: increasing costs (31%), not using the benefit enough to be worth it (30%), and wanting to reduce overall benefit spending (27%)." ”
    Source data from
    2025-05-01
    Accessed
    2026-05-13
    Verification
    Excerpt independently re-fetched and confirmed word-for-word against the cited source during our grounding audit.
    Calculation
    LIMRA's 2025 workplace benefits research. The 30% "not using the benefit enough to be worth it" response among lapsed policyholders is the industry's closest published metric to post-purchase regret for disability insurance buyers, and is used here as the action-side regret_rate anchor (0.30). It aligns with the waste-aversion mechanism documented by Krishnan & Iyer (2022). Note that this population self-selected into lapsing — unconditional buyer regret among all current policyholders is likely lower, so 0.30 is best read as an upper-bound proxy among the subgroup most prone to it.

Sources: inaction

Claim ledger

Every number below is what each source reported, with the verbatim quote we relied on and how we arrived at our figure. Click any link to verify directly.

2/3 sources independently verified verbatim against the cited source

  1. [1] Guardian Life Insurance Company of America — Role of Disability Insurance in Financial Wellness Verified
    Role of Disability Insurance in Financial Wellness
    Statistic
    8 in 10 workers who experienced a disability leave without disability insurance say they have not yet fully recovered financially
    Excerpt
    “"People with disability insurance were less likely to be negatively impacted (38% vs. 62% of those with no disability coverage). Among those with no disability insurance, 8 in 10 say they have not yet fully recovered financially." ”
    Source data from
    2024-01-01
    Accessed
    2026-05-13
    Verification
    Excerpt independently re-fetched and confirmed word-for-word against the cited source during our grounding audit.
    Calculation
    Guardian's workplace benefits study surveyed US full-time workers, of whom 3 in 10 households reported at least one disability leave in the past 10 years. Among those who lacked disability insurance during that leave, 80% (8 in 10) reported incomplete financial recovery. We use 0.80 as the inaction regret rate — not a literal "regret" question, but incomplete financial recovery is the operational consequence that drives retrospective regret about skipping coverage. The insured cohort's 38% negative-impact rate versus the uninsured's 62% negative-impact rate corroborates the large gap. The research highlights give no sample size, so the sample size given above rests on the full report, which the page does not reproduce.
  2. [2] LIMRA — Disability Insurance Awareness Month: Protecting Your Paycheck and Your Future
    Disability Insurance Awareness Month: Protecting Your Paycheck and Your Future
    Statistic
    46% of US adults say they need disability insurance; only 18% report having it; 48% of uninsured say they would tap personal savings if unable to work
    Excerpt
    “"shows that 46% of U.S. adults say they need some sort of disability insurance. Yet, currently, less than 1 in 5 consumers (18%) say they have it … According to 2024 Insurance Barometer Study data, consumers without disability insurance coverage say their families would resort to tapping into personal savings (48%) or retirement funds (26%) to meet their day-to-day expenses." ”
    Source data from
    2024-05-01
    Accessed
    2026-05-13
    Calculation
    LIMRA's 2024 Insurance Barometer Study data. The coverage-gap statistic (46% say they need it; 18% have it) establishes the scale of involuntary non-ownership. The coping- mechanism data (48% would drain savings, 26% retirement funds) illustrates the downstream financial distress that makes inaction the regret-dominant path. Used here as corroborating context, not a direct regret rate.
  3. [3] Council for Disability Income Awareness (CDIA) — Disability Statistics Verified
    Disability Statistics
    Statistic
    Just under 1 in 4 of today's 20-year-olds can expect to be out of work for at least a year due to a disabling condition before reaching normal retirement age (per SSA probability tables); at least 51 million US working adults lack disability insurance beyond basic Social Security coverage (per an ACLI analysis of 2022 Census data); medically related work loss was cited as a contributor in 44.3% of personal bankruptcies (per Himmelstein et al., American Journal of Public Health, 2019)
    Excerpt
    “"Just under one in four of today's 20-year-olds can expect to be out of work for at least a year because of a disabling condition before they reach the normal retirement age." "At least 51 million working adults in the United States are without disability insurance other than the basic coverage available through Social Security." "44.3% specifically citing medically-related work loss as a contributor" [to personal bankruptcy]. ”
    Source data from
    2026-03-30
    Accessed
    2026-07-03
    Verification
    Excerpt independently re-fetched and confirmed word-for-word against the cited source during our grounding audit.
    Calculation
    CDIA's statistics page aggregates three figures used in the body prose that were previously stated without any citation. The 1-in-4 disability-probability figure is attributed by CDIA to SSA's Disability and Death Probability Tables for Insured Workers Who Attain Age 20 in 2025; the figure of 51 million uninsured workers is attributed to an ACLI analysis of 2022 Census data and the 2020 Strategic Business Insights MacroMonitor Household Survey; the 44.3%-of-bankruptcies figure is attributed to Himmelstein, Lawless, Thorne, Foohey & Woolhandler, "Medical Bankruptcy: Still Common Despite the Affordable Care Act," American Journal of Public Health 109, no. 3 (2019): 431-433 -- the body now cites that AJPH study directly for the bankruptcy figure rather than crediting CDIA (a secondary compiler) with having "found" it. Added to ground three previously-uncited body claims; does not change the inaction regret_rate (0.80).

Caveats

The two regret signals are not directly comparable survey instruments — action-side regret is proxied by the stated reason lapsed policyholders give for dropping coverage ("not using the benefit enough to be worth it," a waste-aversion sentiment), while inaction-side regret is measured via post-event financial non-recovery (a consequence proxy, not a self-reported regret question). No published study has directly asked both insured and uninsured workers the same regret question after a disability event, so the regret_delta is an approximation constructed from separate data sources. The inaction group is conditioned on actually experiencing a disability leave — workers who never became disabled and skipped coverage may feel no regret at all, which means the population-level inaction regret rate across all workers is substantially lower than the 80% figure (which applies only to those who needed the coverage). Disability income insurance is also not available or affordable for all workers: self-employed workers, gig workers, and those with pre-existing conditions face access constraints that complicate the action/inaction framing. Premium costs vary significantly with occupation, age, and benefit period. Short-term and long-term disability insurance are distinct products with different elimination periods and benefit durations; the sources above do not consistently separate them.

Raw data: /api/decisions.json

Recently viewed on this device