Lending money to family or friends is a decision where both paths carry substantial downside. Bankrate’s 2019 survey of 2,490 US adults found that 46% of those who lent money to a loved one experienced negative consequences — lost money, damaged credit, or harmed relationships. LendingTree’s parallel survey put direct regret at 24%. On the refusal side, 26% of those who declined to lend say the refusal ended a relationship entirely. The action side carries financial risk; the inaction side carries relational risk.
The difference in regret type is the more informative contrast here. Lenders who regret the decision typically lost money they will not recover — a concrete, quantifiable harm. Refusers who regret it lost a relationship — an emotional, diffuse harm.
The comparison has a fundamental measurement problem: the two sides use different instruments, different survey years, and different definitions of “negative outcome.” The action-side figure, which has no direct measurement, blends direct regret (24%, LendingTree) with broader negative consequences (46%, Bankrate). The 26% for the inaction side measures relationship loss, not self-reported regret. A cleaner comparison would need a single validated instrument applied to both lenders and refusers in the same sample. Until that exists, the takeaway is qualitative: both lending and refusing carry a risk of a bad outcome, but the nature of the harm differs.







