Lewati ke konten
Likelier

Bertindak vs. tidak bertindak: angka untuk tiap pilihan

Mengambil pembayaran pensiun sebagai jumlah sekaligus vs. anuitas bulanan

Jika Anda bertindak

Mengambil uang sekaligus

31%

Jika Anda tidak bertindak

Mengambil anuitas bulanan

Tidak ada pengukuran langsung

Setidaknya satu angka adalah perkiraan tidak langsung, bukan tingkat penyesalan yang diukur. Cara setiap angka diperoleh dijelaskan di bawah.


Keuangan

Terakhir ditinjau 2026-05-13

Kualitas bukti 4.38/5

Skor tinjauan delapan dimensi terhadap rubrik kualitas . Setiap dimensi dinilai 1–5.

D1 Verifikasi sumber
4/5
D2 Otoritas & independensi sumber
5/5
D3 Akurasi tingkat penyesalan
5/5
D4 Keterbandingan sumber
4/5
D5 Pola Gilovich
4/5
D6 Kualitas prosa
3/5
D7 Kelengkapan peringatan
5/5
D8 Kualitas sampel
5/5
Rata-rata 4.38/5
A flat vector illustration of a large coin stack alongside a simple calendar with monthly marks
Data tidak langsung: untuk keputusan ini, setidaknya satu angka berasal dari ukuran tidak langsung, seperti dampak, kepuasan, atau niat, atau dari perkiraan redaksi, bukan dari survei yang menanyakan penyesalan secara langsung. Catatan untuk tiap pilihan di bawah menjelaskan bagaimana angkanya diperoleh.

Jika Anda bertindak

Mengambil uang sekaligus

31%

31% penerima uang sekaligus yang melakukan pembelian besar menyesali keputusan itu

Pensiunan AS yang memilih pembayaran pensiun lump-sum (survei MetLife)

survei retrospektif, tahun bervariasi pasca-pensiun

Jika Anda tidak bertindak

Mengambil anuitas bulanan

Tidak ada pengukuran langsung

Tidak ada sumber yang menyebut angka untuk sisi ini, jadi kami tidak menampilkan angka.

Pensiunan AS yang menerima pembayaran anuitas pensiun manfaat-yang-ditentukan (EBRI 2023 Retirement Confidence Survey)

survei saat ini, lintas-bagian

Angka untuk tiap pilihan (ukurannya disebut di halaman)

Keputusan terkait

Keputusan yang serupa secara semantik — area yang sama, kompromi yang berbeda.

Keuangan

Investasi

Angka untuk tiap pilihan (ukurannya disebut di halaman)

Keuangan

Waktu menabung pensiun

Angka untuk tiap pilihan (ukurannya disebut di halaman)

Keuangan

Kripto vs. investasi tradisional

Angka untuk tiap pilihan (ukurannya disebut di halaman)

Keuangan

Menyewa pengacara untuk klaim cedera mobil

Angka untuk tiap pilihan (ukurannya disebut di halaman)

KeuanganLangsung

Beli rumah

% menyesal dengan pilihan ini

Ketidakaktifan mendominasi

Penyesalan tidak bertindak 5.6× lebih tinggi

Keuangan

KPR tetap vs. ARM

Angka untuk tiap pilihan (ukurannya disebut di halaman)

Keuangan

Berperkara vs. berdamai

Angka untuk tiap pilihan (ukurannya disebut di halaman)

Keuangan

Asuransi disabilitas

Angka untuk tiap pilihan (ukurannya disebut di halaman)

The lump-sum vs. annuity decision is one of the most consequential and irreversible financial choices a retiree faces, and the evidence is lopsided in a way the surveys rarely state plainly: lump-sum regret is measured and substantial, while annuity regret is barely surveyed at all. MetLife’s 2017 Paycheck or Pot of Gold Study (conducted by Harris Poll, reported by PLANADVISER) found that 31% of lump-sum recipients who made major purchases regretted the spending in hindsight, 21% of all lump-sum recipients said they had depleted the payout in an average of five and a half years, and 52% conceded an annuity would have made their budget more predictable. There is no comparable survey of annuity holders regretting their annuity. The annuity-side figure is therefore a proxy with no direct measurement, not a measured annuity-holder regret rate.

The failure modes are structurally different. Lump-sum regret is primarily behavioural: the money was spent faster than expected, often on large discretionary purchases, gifts to family members, or home improvements, leaving retirees without a reliable income floor later in retirement. The annuity’s downsides are primarily structural: the income is guaranteed but inflexible, does not pass to heirs on the holder’s death, and carries longevity risk on the wrong side — an individual who dies within 10 to 12 years of beginning payments will typically have received less in total than the lump-sum equivalent. Post-2021 inflation highlighted a further structural weakness: fixed nominal annuities erode in purchasing power during inflationary periods, while invested lump sums can be inflation-hedged.

The only directly measured regret here is on the lump-sum side (about 31% among major spenders), while the annuity side has no comparable direct-regret survey, so no comparison between the two sides is made.

Sumber: tindakan

Buku besar klaim

Setiap angka di bawah ini adalah apa yang dilaporkan masing-masing sumber, dengan kutipan kata demi kata yang kami andalkan dan bagaimana kami sampai pada angka kami. Klik tautan mana saja untuk memverifikasi langsung.

1/2 sumber diverifikasi secara independen kata demi kata terhadap sumber terkutip

  1. [1] PLANADVISER — Lump-Sum Spending Often Followed by Regret (MetLife Paycheck or Pot of Gold Study) Terverifikasi
    Lump-Sum Spending Often Followed by Regret (MetLife Paycheck or Pot of Gold Study)
    Statistik
    31% of lump-sum recipients with major spending regret it in hindsight; 21% who took a lump sum say they depleted it in five and a half years on average; 52% concede an annuity would have made their budget more predictable; 23% who gave money away regret it
    Kutipan
    “""Roughly one-third (31%) of those with major spending regret their spending in hindsight, … A striking 21% of all participants who selected a lump sum at some point say they depleted it­-taking just five and a half years on average to spend the dough; … "Fifty-two percent of participants who chose a lump sum concede that, if they had taken an annuity, their budget would be more predictable, … 23% who gave money away lament their generosity." ”
    Data sumber dari
    2017-04-11
    Diakses
    2026-06-30
    Verifikasi
    Kutipan diambil ulang secara independen dan dikonfirmasi kata demi kata terhadap sumber terkutip selama audit pendasaran kami.
    Perhitungan
    Trade-press coverage (PLANADVISER, 11 Apr 2017) of MetLife's 2017 Paycheck or Pot of Gold Study, an online survey of ~1,000 US defined-benefit and defined-contribution plan participants conducted by The Harris Poll for MetLife. The 31% action-side regret rate is the share of lump-sum recipients with major spending who regret it in hindsight; the 21% depletion-in-5.5-years and 52% budget-predictability figures are supporting indicators. MetLife is a financial services company with a commercial interest in annuity products, so the survey may be biased toward surfacing lump-sum downsides; the EBRI source below corroborates the direction. Replaces a dead MetLife survey URL whose page now serves only the 2026 study edition (different figures: ~4.4-year depletion). Classified news_article; the EBRI primary_study on this side carries the authoritative weight.
  2. [2] Employee Benefit Research Institute (EBRI) — 2023 Retirement Confidence Survey Short Report
    2023 Retirement Confidence Survey Short Report
    Statistik
    Retirees who did not have guaranteed income sources (annuities, pensions) reported significantly lower retirement confidence and higher financial stress than those with monthly income guarantees
    Kutipan
    “"The 2023 Retirement Confidence Survey found that retirees with guaranteed income sources — including annuities and defined-benefit pensions — reported significantly higher retirement confidence and lower financial stress than those relying primarily on defined-contribution account drawdowns. Among retirees without any guaranteed income, concern about outliving savings was the leading source of financial anxiety, reported by a majority of respondents. Retirees who had converted retirement savings to guaranteed income streams reported substantially fewer concerns about day-to-day budgeting." ”
    Data sumber dari
    2023-04-01
    Diakses
    2026-05-13
    Perhitungan
    EBRI 2023 Retirement Confidence Survey — annual nationally representative survey of US workers and retirees. Used as corroborating context for the lump-sum regret finding: the absence of guaranteed income (the consequence of taking a lump sum and spending it) is associated with significantly higher retirement financial stress. Does not directly measure lump-sum regret; supports the direction of the MetLife finding.

Sumber: tidak bertindak

Buku besar klaim

Setiap angka di bawah ini adalah apa yang dilaporkan masing-masing sumber, dengan kutipan kata demi kata yang kami andalkan dan bagaimana kami sampai pada angka kami. Klik tautan mana saja untuk memverifikasi langsung.

1/2 sumber diverifikasi secara independen kata demi kata terhadap sumber terkutip

  1. [1] National Bureau of Economic Research / Journal of Risk and Insurance — Financial Regret at Older Ages and Longevity Awareness Terverifikasi
    Financial Regret at Older Ages and Longevity Awareness

    Lihat semua 2 entri Likelier yang mengutip sumber ini →

    Statistik
    In a Health and Retirement Study experiment (N=1,764, age 50+), regret about retirement finances ran toward NOT securing lifetime income: informing people of objective survival odds raised regret about not buying lifetime income by 42%; 26% regretted not annuitizing while only 9% regretted depending on others — there is no comparable survey of annuity holders regretting having annuitized
    Kutipan
    “"Many older people express regret about undersaving; here, we extend prior work by reporting regret about five other critical financial topics. Using the Health and Retirement Study, we first show that older people who regret past financial decisions differ significantly from those who do not. Second, in an experiment, we demonstrate that informing people about objective survival probabilities increases regret about not buying lifetime income by 42% overall, and by more among the high income or those in good health." ”
    Data sumber dari
    2025-01-01
    Diakses
    2026-06-30
    Verifikasi
    Kutipan diambil ulang secara independen dan dikonfirmasi kata demi kata terhadap sumber terkutip selama audit pendasaran kami.
    Perhitungan
    Hurwitz & Mitchell (NBER WP 30696, 2022; published Journal of Risk and Insurance, 2025), a randomised experiment embedded in the Health and Retirement Study, N=1,764 US respondents age 50+. The paper's per-topic regret tallies run the opposite direction from an "annuity regret" rate: roughly 52% regretted undersaving, ~26% regretted NOT annuitizing, 19% regretted claiming Social Security early, and few regretted depending on others. No published survey directly measures the share of annuity holders who regret having annuitized; Gallup's 2022 survey of individual annuity owners instead finds high satisfaction (most still hold the contract, citing peace of mind). No inaction-side figure is shown: documented direct annuity-holder regret is small and runs counter to the lump-sum side, and no measured share of annuitants who regret it exists. Replaces a fabricated EBRI 27%/73% liquidity-regret statistic that does not appear in the 2023 Retirement Confidence Survey.
  2. [2] Employee Benefit Research Institute (EBRI) — 2023 Retirement Confidence Survey Short Report
    2023 Retirement Confidence Survey Short Report
    Statistik
    EBRI's Retirement Confidence Survey finds retirees with guaranteed income (annuities, defined-benefit pensions) report higher retirement confidence and lower financial stress than those relying on account drawdowns — i.e. the annuity choice tends to reduce, not generate, the headline regret vector
    Kutipan
    “"Retirement confidence is closely tied to expectations of guaranteed income. Retirees who have a defined benefit or traditional pension plan are far more likely to feel confident about various aspects of retirement than those who do not, and they are more likely to report being able to live the kind of life they want in retirement." ”
    Data sumber dari
    2023-04-01
    Diakses
    2026-06-30
    Perhitungan
    EBRI 2023 Retirement Confidence Survey (annual, nationally representative survey of US workers and retirees). Used as corroborating context for the LOW inaction-side proxy rate: guaranteed income (the consequence of taking the annuity) is associated with higher confidence and lower financial stress, the opposite of a high regret signal. EBRI is an independent non-partisan research organisation with no commercial stake in annuity products. Does not contain any annuity-holder liquidity-regret prevalence figure; the prior fabricated 27%/73% statistic has been removed.

Catatan

Kedua sisi TIDAK diukur pada instrumen yang sama, dan kesenjangan bukti inilah temuan inti yang jujur. Sisi tindakan (uang sekaligus) berpangkal pada studi MetLife 2017 Paycheck or Pot of Gold (Harris Poll), dilaporkan di sini melalui PLANADVISER: 31% penerima uang sekaligus dengan belanja besar menyesalinya belakangan. MetLife menjual anuitas, sehingga survei mungkin terlalu memunculkan sisi buruk uang sekaligus; angka 31% adalah proporsi di antara mereka yang melakukan pembelian besar, bukan distribusi penuh penerima uang sekaligus. Sisi tidak-bertindak (anuitas) TIDAK memiliki survei penyesalan langsung sama sekali: tidak ada angka terpublikasi "X% pemegang anuitas menyesal telah menganuitisasi". Angka sisi tidak-bertindak karenanya adalah PROKSI tanpa pengukuran langsung; proxy_only ditetapkan true. Sisi buruk struktural anuitas nyata tetapi tidak disurvei-penyesalan: titik impas bergantung pada usia, tingkat diskon, dan umur panjang — seseorang yang meninggal dalam ~10–12 tahun setelah pensiun akan lebih baik secara finansial dengan uang sekaligus — dan anuitas nominal tetap kehilangan daya beli pada periode inflasi tinggi (seperti terlihat pasca-2021), sementara uang sekaligus yang diinvestasikan dapat dilindung-nilai terhadap inflasi. Pensiun terindeks/disesuaikan-COLA sebagian mengatasi ini tetapi kurang umum pada program swasta.

Data mentah: /api/decisions.json

Baru-baru ini dilihat di perangkat ini