Zum Inhalt springen
Likelier

Handeln vs. Nichthandeln: Zahl für jede Wahl

Freiwillig zum Militär gehen vs. nicht dienen

Wenn du handelst

Zum Militär gehen

21%

Wenn du nicht handelst

Keinen Militärdienst leisten

Keine direkte Messung

Mindestens eine Zahl ist eine indirekte Schätzung, keine gemessene Reuequote. Wie jede Zahl entstanden ist, steht weiter unten.


Lebensstil

Zuletzt überprüft 2026-05-09

Evidenzqualität 3.75/5

Bewertungsergebnis nach acht Dimensionen gemäß der Qualitätsrubrik . Jede Dimension wird mit 1–5 bewertet.

D1 Quellenüberprüfung
4/5
D2 Quellenautorität & Unabhängigkeit
4/5
D3 Genauigkeit der Bedauernsrate
1/5
D4 Vergleichbarkeit der Quellen
2/5
D5 Gilovich-Muster
5/5
D6 Prosaqualität
5/5
D7 Vollständigkeit der Einschränkungen
5/5
D8 Stichprobenqualität
4/5
Durchschnitt 3.75/5
A set of military dog tags beside a civilian briefcase, separated by a line on a plain surface.
Indirekte Daten: Für diese Entscheidung stammt mindestens eine Zahl aus einem indirekten Maß wie Folgen, Zufriedenheit oder Absicht oder aus einer redaktionellen Schätzung statt aus einer Umfrage, die direkt nach Reue fragt. Die Hinweise zu beiden Seiten weiter unten erklären, wie die jeweilige Zahl entstanden ist.

Wenn du handelst

Zum Militär gehen

21%

21 % der Veteranen sagen, sie würden ihren Militärdienst nicht wiederholen (d. h. implizite Reuequote aus der DAV-Umfrage 2015)

US-Veteranen aller Generationen, vom Zweiten Weltkrieg bis zur Post-9/11-Ära

retrospektiv, kein fester Zeitraum

Wenn du nicht handelst

Keinen Militärdienst leisten

Keine direkte Messung

Keine Quelle nennt für diese Seite eine Zahl, deshalb zeigen wir keine.

US-zivile Erwachsene, die einen Militärdienst erwogen, aber nicht antraten (keine direkte Umfrage verfügbar)

retrospektiv, kein fester Zeitraum

Zahl für jede Wahl (was sie misst, steht auf der Seite)

Verwandte Entscheidungen

Semantisch ähnliche Entscheidungen — gleiches Terrain, andere Abwägungen.

lifestyle

Korea: Militärdienst vs. Zivildienst

Zahl für jede Wahl (was sie misst, steht auf der Seite)

career

Studienentscheidung

Zahl für jede Wahl (was sie misst, steht auf der Seite)

lifestyle

Tattoo

Zahl für jede Wahl (was sie misst, steht auf der Seite)

family

Kinder bekommen

Zahl für jede Wahl (was sie misst, steht auf der Seite)

lifestyle

Vegetarische Ernährung

Zahl für jede Wahl (was sie misst, steht auf der Seite)

lifestyle

Ins Ausland ziehen

Zahl für jede Wahl (was sie misst, steht auf der Seite)

lifestyle

Gap Year vs. direkt ins Studium

Zahl für jede Wahl (was sie misst, steht auf der Seite)

career

Homeoffice vs Büro

Zahl für jede Wahl (was sie misst, steht auf der Seite)

The DAV Veterans Pulse Survey of 2015, the largest multi-generational survey of US veterans (n = 1,701, nationally representative of approximately 22 million veterans from WWII through post-9/11 eras), found that 79% would, if they had to do it over, repeat their military service. The implied action-side rate, the complement of that 79% (those who would not or are uncertain whether they would repeat), is the primary metric for this entry. Pew Research’s 2011 survey of 1,853 veterans, including 712 post-9/11 veterans, found that 96% were proud of their service, 82% said their service helped them appreciate life more, 93% said it helped them mature, and 90% said it taught them to work with others. The two surveys converge on a picture of low to moderate action regret, with pride nearly universal and the “would serve again” rate consistently above 75%.

The inaction side has no direct survey data, so it carries no reliable regret estimate. No national survey was identified that asks non-veteran civilians whether they regret not serving in the military, and this gap in the literature is notable. The inaction side therefore has no direct measurement.

Only the action side carries a measured rate, and even it carries substantial uncertainty. The action side benefits from two large nationally representative samples with near-direct “would serve again” questions, but survivorship bias is significant: veterans who developed severe PTSD or service-related disabilities are under-represented in voluntary panels, and active-duty satisfaction has declined sharply since 2019 (Blue Star Families found only 32% of active-duty families would recommend service in 2023, down from 55% in 2016), suggesting the action-side regret may understate more recent cohorts. This entry documents the state of the evidence rather than a resolved bilateral comparison: strong action-side data, no inaction-side survey, and therefore no honest basis for declaring which side regrets more.

Quellen: Handeln

Quellenregister

Jede Zahl unten ist das, was die jeweilige Quelle berichtet hat — mit dem wörtlichen Zitat, auf das wir uns stützen, und wie wir zu unserer Zahl gelangt sind. Klicke auf einen Link, um direkt zu prüfen.

  1. [1] DAV (Disabled American Veterans) Veterans Pulse Survey via PR Newswire — Landmark Survey Finds Veterans of All Generations Would Repeat their Military Service, But Don't Feel Supported by Government and the American Public
    Landmark Survey Finds Veterans of All Generations Would Repeat their Military Service, But Don't Feel Supported by Government and the American Public
    Statistik
    79% of veterans across all generations (WWII through post-9/11) said they would, if they had to do it all over again, repeat their military service.
    Auszug
    “"Nearly eight in 10 would, if they had to do it all over again, repeat their service." ”
    Quelldaten von
    2015-11-10
    Abgerufen
    2026-05-09
    Berechnung
    DAV Veterans Pulse Survey, conducted by global research firm GfK using KnowledgePanel. The survey was completed by 1,701 veterans, nationally representative of America's then approximately 22 million veterans, spanning WWII through post-9/11 eras. The 79% "would repeat" figure implies an action regret rate of approximately 21% (the share who would not or are uncertain whether they would repeat their service). The survey asked directly about whether veterans would make the same choice again, making it a near-direct regret measure. Note: "would not repeat" is not identical to "regrets joining" — some who would not repeat may still view the service as valuable but would not recommend it to others, or are uncertain. The 21% is therefore a plausible upper bound on the action regret rate, not a confirmed regret prevalence.
  2. [2] Pew Research Center — Chapter 1: Overview — War and Sacrifice in the Post-9/11 Era
    Chapter 1: Overview — War and Sacrifice in the Post-9/11 Era
    Statistik
    96% of post-9/11 veterans say they are proud of their service; 82% say their military service helped them appreciate life more; 74% say it helped them get ahead in life.
    Auszug
    “"Post-9/11 veterans are proud of their service (96%), appreciate life more (82%) and believe that their military service has helped them get ahead in life (74%). Large majorities say that serving in the military has been either very or fairly useful in helping them become more mature (93%); gain self-confidence (90%); learn to work with other people (90%); and prepare for a job or career (72%)." ”
    Quelldaten von
    2011-10-05
    Abgerufen
    2026-07-07
    Berechnung
    Pew Research Center "War and Sacrifice in the Post-9/11 Era" survey of 1,853 veterans (including 712 who served after 9/11), Chapter 1: Overview (corrected from Chapter 2, previously mis-cited here -- Chapter 2 covers war-policy attitudes and does not contain these figures). The 96% pride rate is not a regret rate; it measures emotional response to service, not whether veterans would make the same choice again. Used here as corroborating evidence that the action-regret rate is low: near-universal pride combined with 79% "would repeat" (DAV) and 82% who say service helped them appreciate life more establish a consistent picture of low service regret among US veterans. (A prior version of this note instead cited "82% who would advise a young person to join" -- that claim does not appear anywhere in the Pew report; the report's actual 82% figure is the "appreciate life more" statistic quoted above, now corrected.) The 4% who are not proud provides a directional lower bound on regret.

Quellen: Nichthandeln

Quellenregister

Jede Zahl unten ist das, was die jeweilige Quelle berichtet hat — mit dem wörtlichen Zitat, auf das wir uns stützen, und wie wir zu unserer Zahl gelangt sind. Klicke auf einen Link, um direkt zu prüfen.

  1. [1] RAND Corporation — What Americans Think About Veterans and Military Service: Findings from a Nationally Representative Survey
    What Americans Think About Veterans and Military Service: Findings from a Nationally Representative Survey
    Statistik
    54% of Americans would discourage a young person from enlisting as an enlisted service member, but 61% would encourage service via ROTC or a service academy. The split suggests the path to service matters more than service itself.
    Auszug
    “"A majority of Americans (54.4 percent) would discourage a young person close to them from enlisting in the military, but a majority of Americans (61.2 percent) would encourage a young person to join the military via Reserve Officers' Training Corps (ROTC) or a service academy (i.e., as an officer)." ”
    Quelldaten von
    2023-12-14
    Abgerufen
    2026-05-09
    Berechnung
    RAND RRA1363-7, nationally representative American Life Panel surveys (February and June 2022). The 54.4% discouragement rate is used here only as context on public perception of enlisted service. It is NOT a regret rate for non-veterans: it measures what adults would advise a young person, not whether they themselves regret not serving. No published survey directly asks non-veterans "do you regret not joining the military?" Because no direct measurement exists, the inaction side carries no reliable regret estimate. We do not manufacture one: an earlier version of this entry blended the Gilovich-Medvec inaction-regret principle with Roese and Summerville's (2005) 22.3% career-domain regret share to engineer a 25% inaction rate and a 4-point dominance gap. That composite was not a measured value and has been removed. No inaction-side figure is shown, and the pattern is recorded as balanced rather than inaction-dominant.
  2. [2] Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin (APA) — What We Regret Most ... and Why
    What We Regret Most ... and Why

    Alle 10 Likelier-Einträge mit dieser Quelle ansehen →

    Statistik
    Career accounts for 22.3% of top lifetime regrets in a meta-analysis of 11 regret-ranking datasets; people most regret decisions in domains where they see the largest missed opportunities for change and growth.
    Auszug
    “"A meta-analysis of 11 regret ranking studies revealed that the top six biggest regrets in life center on (in descending order) education, career, romance, parenting, the self, and leisure." ”
    Quelldaten von
    2005-09-01
    Abgerufen
    2026-05-09
    Berechnung
    Roese and Summerville (2005) meta-analysis of 11 regret-ranking studies. Career ranks second among lifetime regret domains (22.3%), after education (32.2%). This share describes the relative ranking of regret DOMAINS in the general population; it does not measure how many non-veterans regret not serving, and Roese and Summerville never study military service. It is cited here only to show that career/identity choices are a leading regret domain in theory — not as a basis for any specific inaction-regret percentage. The prior version of this entry mis-used the 22.3% figure (plus the Gilovich-Medvec inaction-dominance principle) to back-derive a 25% inaction rate; that derivation was unsupported and has been removed. The inaction side now carries no reliable estimate.

Einschränkungen

THE INACTION SIDE HAS NO DIRECT SURVEY. The action-side rate is derived as the complement of the DAV Veterans Pulse Survey 2015 "would repeat service" figure (79% would repeat, the remainder would not or are uncertain). "Would not repeat" is not identical to "regrets joining" — it includes those who are uncertain or who view the choice as context- dependent. The Pew 2011 finding that 96% of post-9/11 veterans are proud of their service converges with the DAV figure to establish a low-to- moderate action regret profile. Both surveys are subject to survivorship bias: veterans who developed severe PTSD or declined participation are under-represented in voluntary panels. Active-duty satisfaction has been declining since 2019 (Blue Star Families MFLS: 55% recommend service in 2016 vs. 32% in 2023), so the action regret may underestimate regret in more recent cohorts. THE INACTION SIDE HAS NO RELIABLE ESTIMATE: no national survey was found that directly asks non-veterans whether they regret not serving. The inaction side is shown without a figure to signal that it is unmeasured; readers should treat the inaction side as unknown. This entry cannot be considered a bilateral regret pair in the usual sense: only the action side is measured; the inaction side is not. The cultural context of military service varies enormously: the analysis applies to the US voluntary military, not to conscript armies or wartime service where the choice set is not voluntary.

Rohdaten: /api/decisions.json

Zuletzt auf diesem Gerät angesehen