Skip to content
Likelier

Action vs. inaction: figure for each choice

Appealing a court judgment vs accepting the original ruling

If you act

Appealing the court ruling

86%

If you don't

Accepting the original ruling without appeal

60%

At least one figure is an indirect estimate, not a measured regret rate. How each figure was built is shown below.


Financial

Last reviewed 2026-05-09

Evidence quality 3.63/5

Eight-dimension review score against the quality rubric . Each dimension scored 1–5.

D1 Source verification
4/5
D2 Source authority & independence
4/5
D3 Regret-rate accuracy
1/5
D4 Source comparability
2/5
D5 Gilovich pattern
5/5
D6 Prose quality
4/5
D7 Caveat completeness
5/5
D8 Sample quality
4/5
Average 3.63/5
A courthouse with a split path: one leading upward to a higher court, the other leading back to a street-level exit.
Indirect data: for this decision at least one figure comes from an indirect measure, such as outcomes, satisfaction or intent, or from an editorial estimate, rather than from a direct regret survey. The notes for each side below say how its figure was built.

If you act

Appealing the court ruling

86%

~86% of civil appeals in federal court do not result in reversal of the lower court's judgment

Private civil litigants in US federal courts of appeals

calendar year 2015 reversal rates, checked against 2021 merits dispositions

If you don't

Accepting the original ruling without appeal

60%

~60% proxy: share of tried civil cases with an adverse trial judgment where the losing side does not appeal at all (federal appellate-filing data)

Civil litigants who received adverse judgments at trial in US federal courts

federal civil cases terminating in fiscal years 1988-2000

Figure for each choice (the measure is named on the page)

Related decisions

Semantically similar decisions — same territory, different trade-offs.

Financial

Litigate vs settle

Figure for each choice (the measure is named on the page)

Financial

Hire a lawyer for an auto injury claim

Figure for each choice (the measure is named on the page)

Financial

Car price negotiation

Figure for each choice (the measure is named on the page)

Financial

Home renovation

Figure for each choice (the measure is named on the page)

Financial

Lending to family

Figure for each choice (the measure is named on the page)

Financial

Fixed vs. ARM mortgage

Figure for each choice (the measure is named on the page)

career

Salary negotiation

Figure for each choice (the measure is named on the page)

Financial

Gift down payment vs. protect savings

Figure for each choice (the measure is named on the page)

In private civil disputes in US federal courts, roughly 86% of appellants do not achieve reversal of the lower court’s judgment (approximately 14% reversal rate), the most favorable civil category; across the overall caseload the reversal rate is lower still (8.5% in 2021). Spending the time and money to appeal results in the original ruling standing in the vast majority of cases. On the inaction side, federal appellate-filing data suggests a majority of civil litigants who lose at trial never appeal at all: an analysis of federal civil cases found a 39.6% appeal rate among tried cases, implying that roughly 60% go uncontested — for some out of cost, lack of counsel, or low awareness of appellate rights, and for others because they correctly judge their odds of reversal are poor — leaving many with outcomes they believed were wrong but never contested.

The decision to appeal sits in a distinctive position among legal choices: it is almost always made after an already costly first proceeding, the odds are quantifiably long before the filing is made, and the costs of the action are immediate while potential benefits are speculative. Appeals courts are explicitly deferential to trial courts — the “any reasonable trier of fact” standard in civil cases means that many judgments that appear wrong to the losing party are legally unreviewable. The anti-plaintiff pattern in appellate outcomes shows up clearly in the available data: one Cornell Law/Journal of Empirical Legal Studies analysis found plaintiff appellants achieved reversal in about 4% of adverse trial judgments, versus about 10% for defendants — a pattern that analysis found held across case types — meaning individuals bringing claims may face steeper uphill odds than institutional defendants with experienced appellate counsel.

The regret calculus here is complicated by the multiple functions an appeal can serve. Some appellants file to force a settlement renegotiation, not because they expect to win at the appellate level — in those cases, even an unsuccessful appeal may achieve the desired outcome and generate no regret. The inaction side is equally ambiguous: many litigants who accept an adverse judgment have correctly assessed that their grounds for appeal are thin, and acceptance is a rational response rather than resigned defeat. The Gilovich temporal model predicts that regret about inaction grows over time — people who never fought a ruling they thought unjust may carry that grievance for years — while the disappointment of a failed appeal fades as appellants adapt to the outcome. The point estimates here are the weakest in this dataset and should be read as directional rather than quantitative.

Sources: action

Claim ledger

Every number below is what each source reported, with the verbatim quote we relied on and how we arrived at our figure. Click any link to verify directly.

  1. [1] Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts — Just the Facts: U.S. Courts of Appeals
    Just the Facts: U.S. Courts of Appeals
    Statistic
    Fewer than 9% of total appeals in 2015 resulted in reversals; private civil cases saw the highest civil reversal rate at 14.2%
    Excerpt
    “Fewer than 9 percent of total appeals resulted in reversals of lower court decisions in 2015. [...] Table 2 U.S. Courts of Appeals Percentage Reversed Calendar Years 2011-2015 Total Criminal Prisoner Petitions U.S. Civil Private Civil Bankruptcy Adminstrative Appeals [...] 2015 8.6 6.9 4.6 4.2 14.2 24.4 7.8 ”
    Source data from
    2016-12-20
    Accessed
    2026-07-07
    Calculation
    US Courts administrative data for 2015. The 14.2% reversal rate for private civil cases is the highest of the three civil categories in that table (prisoner petitions 4.6%, U.S. civil 4.2%, private civil 14.2%) and is used as the most favorable civil benchmark. Under this rate, approximately 86% of private civil appellants do not obtain a reversal. The 2021 table cited below puts the overall reversal rate at about 8.5% and the rate for Other Private Civil appeals at about 11.5%, so the 2015 figure is the more generous of the two years for private civil cases; it is kept as the headline basis. The action regret proxy rate of 0.86 = 1 - 0.14 (using the most favorable civil category). It represents the share of appellants who spend money and time on appeal and do not achieve reversal. This is outcome inferiority rather than felt regret, but it is the closest available proxy.
  2. [2] Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts — Table B-5. U.S. Courts of Appeals—Decisions in Cases Terminated on the Merits (12-Month Period Ending December 31, 2021)
    Table B-5. U.S. Courts of Appeals—Decisions in Cases Terminated on the Merits (12-Month Period Ending December 31, 2021)
    Statistic
    Of 28,189 cases terminated on the merits in the 12-month period ending December 31, 2021, 2,354 were reversed; the table shows an overall percent reversed of 8.5 (computed by the table without original proceedings) and 11.5 for Other Private Civil (654 of 5,696 terminated on the merits, 11.48% by own calculation)
    Excerpt
    “Percent reversed not computed for original proceedings because of their difference from appeals, nor are original proceedings included in the percentage of total appeals reversed. ”
    Source data from
    2021-12-31
    Accessed
    2026-11-07
    Calculation
    2021 data from Table B-5 of the Statistical Tables for the Federal Judiciary (12-month period ending December 31, 2021), read from the downloadable spreadsheet because the web page itself loads the table by script. The spreadsheet stores the percent reversed unrounded and displays it to one decimal place: 8.5 for the total row (stored value 8.483) and 11.5 for Other Private Civil (stored value 11.48). The six outcome columns of the total row add up to the merits total (18656 + 3131 + 2354 + 618 + 220 + 3210 = 28189). The 8.5 percent is not 2,354 divided by 28,189 (that quotient is about 8.35%): the table leaves original proceedings and miscellaneous applications (3,021 terminations, 219 reversals) out of the percentage, and 2,135 reversals among 25,168 other terminations gives 8.48%. Other Private Civil appeals show 654 of 5,696 reversed, 11.48% by own calculation, which matches the stored value. The headline basis stays the 2015 private civil rate of 14.2%, giving an implied 85.8% non-reversal rate, rounded to 0.86 for the action regret proxy; on the 2021 Other Private Civil rate the same proxy would be about 0.89.

Sources: inaction

Claim ledger

Every number below is what each source reported, with the verbatim quote we relied on and how we arrived at our figure. Click any link to verify directly.

  1. [1] Legal Services Corporation / NORC at the University of Chicago — The Justice Gap: The Unmet Civil Legal Needs of Low-Income Americans (2022)
    The Justice Gap: The Unmet Civil Legal Needs of Low-Income Americans (2022)

    See all 2 Likelier entries citing this source →

    Statistic
    92% of the civil legal problems reported by low-income Americans did not get any or enough legal help
    Excerpt
    “The study reveals that 92% of the civil legal problems reported by low-income Americans did not get any or enough legal help. ”
    Source data from
    2022-04-01
    Accessed
    2026-05-09
    Calculation
    Retained as background context only. This report documents severe access-to-justice constraints in US civil legal aid generally, but it contains no statistic on appeal rates or on litigants who forgo appealing a judgment specifically, so it is not used to derive the inaction-side regret_rate. It supports the qualitative point that cost barriers and lack of counsel are real and large, which may explain part of why civil litigants who lose at trial do not appeal — see the Eisenberg & Clermont source below for the actual regret_rate derivation.
  2. [2] Cornell Law School / Journal of Empirical Legal Studies — Appeal Rates and Outcomes in Tried and Nontried Cases: Further Exploration of Anti-Plaintiff Appellate Outcomes
    Appeal Rates and Outcomes in Tried and Nontried Cases: Further Exploration of Anti-Plaintiff Appellate Outcomes
    Statistic
    The appeal rate is 39.6% in tried civil cases (versus 10.0% in nontried cases); the complement implies about 60% of tried-case losers do not appeal at all
    Excerpt
    “"Federal data sets covering district court and appellate court civil cases for cases terminating in fiscal years 1988 through 2000 are analyzed. Appeals are filed in 10.9 percent of filed cases, and 21.0 percent of cases if one limits the sample to cases with a definitive judgment for plaintiff or defendant. The appeal rate is 39.6 percent in tried cases compared to 10.0 percent of nontried cases. … Defendants achieve reversal of adverse trial court judgments in about 10 percent of filed cases and suffer affirmance in about 15 percent of such cases. Plaintiffs achieve reversal in about 4 percent of adverse trial court judgments and suffer affirmance in about 16 percent of such cases." ”
    Source data from
    2004-11-01
    Accessed
    2026-07-07
    Calculation
    Eisenberg & Clermont's Cornell study of federal civil cases terminating in fiscal years 1988-2000 (Journal of Empirical Legal Studies, 2004). The paper reports a 39.6% appeal rate in tried cases — cases that reached a trial-level judgment, matching this decision's "adverse judgment at trial" population. Because appeals are filed overwhelmingly by the losing or aggrieved side, this appeal rate is used as a proxy for the share of trial losers who contest the judgment; its complement, 1 - 0.396 = 0.604, rounded to 0.60, is the inaction-side regret proxy — the share who do not appeal at all. This replaces a prior "roughly one-third" estimate that this entry's own calculation_notes previously admitted had no traceable derivation from any cited source; that figure has been removed as unsupported. This remains a non-appeal rate, not a felt-regret rate — it does not separate rational acceptance (correctly assessed low odds, cost) from genuine regret, and the underlying data is federal, 1988-2000 vintage, not a current nationally representative sample. The reversal figures above (4% plaintiffs, ~10% defendants) corroborate the anti-plaintiff pattern discussed elsewhere in this entry but are not used in the regret_rate calculation.

Caveats

PROXY MEASUREMENTS ON BOTH SIDES — the regret_delta of 0.26 should be treated with caution. The action-side rate (0.86) is the complement of the reversal rate for private civil cases (14.2%), the highest-reversal civil category. It measures outcome inferiority, not felt regret: many appellants knew they had low odds and appealed anyway for delay, leverage in settlement negotiations, or to preserve rights — they may not regret appealing even after losing. The inaction-side rate (0.60) is the complement of the 39.6% tried-case appeal rate reported by Eisenberg & Clermont (Journal of Empirical Legal Studies, 2004); it measures the share of trial losers who never appeal at all, not felt regret about accepting the judgment, and the underlying data is federal civil litigation from 1988-2000. A prior version of this entry used an uncited "roughly one-third" inaction estimate that its own calculation_notes admitted had no traceable source; that figure has been replaced with this grounded appeal-rate proxy. Both sides measure different things (failure to reverse vs. failure to even try), so the 0.26 delta should be read as directional, not precise. The Gilovich temporal model would predict that inaction regret grows over time (people who accepted unjust rulings may increasingly regret not fighting) while action regret fades (appellants who lost eventually accept it), which could narrow or reverse this gap at longer time horizons than either source measures. Civil vs. criminal appeals have very different dynamics. State court appeal patterns differ from federal. The entry describes federal civil appeals only.

Raw data: /api/decisions.json

Recently viewed on this device