Перейти к содержанию
Likelier

Действие и бездействие: число для каждого выбора

Настаивать на лечении зависимости у члена семьи или ждать, пока он сам обратится за помощью

Если вы действуете

Инициировал или организовал поступление на лечение

38%

Если вы бездействуете

Ждал, пока человек самостоятельно обратится за помощью

67%

Хотя бы одно число является косвенной оценкой, а не измеренной долей сожалеющих. Как получено каждое число, описано ниже.


Здоровье

Последнее обновление 2026-05-22

Качество доказательств 4.25/5

Оценка по восьми измерениям согласно рубрике качества . Каждое измерение оценивается от 1 до 5.

D1 Проверка источников
5/5
D2 Авторитетность и независимость источника
5/5
D3 Точность уровня сожаления
2/5
D4 Сопоставимость источников
2/5
D5 Шаблон Гиловича
5/5
D6 Качество текста
5/5
D7 Полнота оговорок
5/5
D8 Качество выборки
5/5
Среднее 4.25/5
An open doorway leading into a treatment facility on the left, and an empty chair at a kitchen table with an untouched phone on the right
Косвенные данные: по этому решению хотя бы один показатель получен из косвенной меры, такой как последствия, удовлетворённость или намерение, либо из редакционной оценки, а не из прямого опроса о сожалении. В примечаниях к каждой стороне ниже описано, как получен показатель.

Если вы действуете

Инициировал или организовал поступление на лечение

38%

38% семейно инициированных интервенций не достигают вхождения в лечение (приближение через неучастие)

Обеспокоенные значимые другие лиц, устойчивых к лечению, с расстройством употребления психоактивных веществ

6-месячное наблюдение после интервенции

Если вы бездействуете

Ждал, пока человек самостоятельно обратится за помощью

67%

67% семей нелеченых лиц сообщили о задержке обращения за помощью, 88,9% сообщили о трудностях эмоциональной адаптации (приближение через бремя)

Члены семей лиц с расстройством употребления психоактивных веществ, в основном нелеченых

поперечно, ретроспективно; данные собраны июнь 2012 – июль 2013

Число для каждого выбора (что именно измерено, указано на странице)

Похожие решения

Семантически близкие решения — та же область, другие компромиссы.

Здоровье

Лечение зависимости vs отказ от лечения

Число для каждого выбора (что именно измерено, указано на странице)

family

Раскрытие зависимости семье

Число для каждого выбора (что именно измерено, указано на странице)

Здоровье

MAT vs воздержание при опиоидной зависимости

Число для каждого выбора (что именно измерено, указано на странице)

family

Дом престарелых vs домашний уход

Число для каждого выбора (что именно измерено, указано на странице)

familyПрямые

Разреши семейное донорство органов vs. откажи

% сожалеют об этом выборе

Преобладает бездействие

Сожаление о бездействии в 6.8× выше

family

Спасать против дать разобраться

Число для каждого выбора (что именно измерено, указано на странице)

Здоровье

MAID vs. паллиативная помощь

Число для каждого выбора (что именно измерено, указано на странице)

family

Парная терапия vs отказ от неё

Число для каждого выбора (что именно измерено, указано на странице)

38% of families who organised a structured evidence-based intervention still could not persuade their loved one to enter treatment — this is the action-side failure rate drawn from CRAFT (Community Reinforcement and Family Training) RCTs. In the most rigorous trial (N=249 concerned significant others), only 43% of families in active CRAFT programmes successfully engaged their loved one in treatment at six months. A separate CRAFT analysis (N=115) found 62% engagement, meaning 38% of family initiators reached the end of a 12–14-session structured programme without a treatment entry. Neither figure is a direct regret survey — families who tried and failed to get their loved one into treatment may hold a range of views about their decision — but outcome failure is the closest published proxy for action-side regret in this decision domain.

The inaction side carries a heavier documented burden. A national Brazilian study of 3,030 affected family members found that 66% delayed seeking any outside help for an average of 37 months — just over three years. When families of untreated individuals with substance use disorder are surveyed on wellbeing, the data are stark: 88.9% reported significant emotional adjustment difficulties and 51.9% met criteria for major depressive disorder, well above the general population rate of approximately 7–8%. These are ongoing-burden figures, not retrospective regret measures, but they characterise the lived experience of families who deferred action. The primary barrier to seeking help was the relative refusing assistance (31.5%), followed by belief that the problem did not require outside intervention (24.0%) — attitudes that often persist until a crisis forces the issue.

Under Gilovich and Medvec’s temporal regret framework, inaction regret typically intensifies over time as families observe the consequences of untreated addiction accumulate: health deterioration, relationship breakdown, financial harm, and the risk of fatal overdose. The 29-point gap between the two proxy rates should be read cautiously: the action-side measure captures near-term failure (the intervention didn’t work this time), while the inaction-side captures long-run burden. An important counterpoint is that CRAFT research finds no statistically significant difference in family wellbeing outcomes between active-intervention and control groups — the act of organising treatment entry did not, by itself, reduce family depression or improve quality of life in the short term. Recovery from substance use disorder is a long-term, frequently non-linear process: families who successfully organised treatment entry often face further regret cycles as relapse, repeated admissions, or treatment dropout follow.

Источники: действие

Реестр утверждений

Каждое число ниже — это то, что сообщил источник, с дословной цитатой, на которую мы опирались, и тем, как мы пришли к нашей цифре. Нажмите на ссылку, чтобы проверить самостоятельно.

1/2 источников независимо дословно сверены с указанным источником

  1. [1] Drug and Alcohol Dependence (PMC) — Primary Outcome from a cluster-randomized trial of three formats for delivering Community Reinforcement and Family Training (CRAFT) to the significant others of problem drinkers Проверено
    Primary Outcome from a cluster-randomized trial of three formats for delivering Community Reinforcement and Family Training (CRAFT) to the significant others of problem drinkers
    Статистика
    43% of CSOs who received individual or group CRAFT successfully engaged their loved one in treatment at 6 months; 57% did not achieve treatment entry
    Выдержка
    “"An additional analysis (see supplementary table 1 ) showed an IP treatment engagement rate of 43% after six months among the CSOs who received individual or group CRAFT, and the corresponding rate in the control group was 32%." ”
    Данные источника:
    2022-04-01
    Дата обращения
    2026-05-22
    Проверка
    Выдержка независимо повторно загружена и подтверждена слово в слово по указанному источнику в ходе нашей проверки достоверности.
    Расчёт
    Cluster-RCT, N=249 concerned significant others (CSOs) randomised to group CRAFT (n=88), individual CRAFT (n=96), or self-help control (n=65). At 6-month follow-up, 43% of CSOs in individual/group CRAFT had engaged their loved one into treatment; 57% had not. Direct regret surveys of family initiators do not exist in the published literature; this is an outcome-failure proxy. `proxy_only: true` is set. The rate 1 - 0.43 = 0.57 is not used as the action-side rate, because it conflates all non-entry outcomes (patient not yet ready, family withdrew effort, patient died, etc.). A more conservative proxy: the second trial (PMC5690811, n=115) found 62% CRAFT engagement vs 37% Al-Anon/Nar-Anon; inverted CRAFT = 38% non-engagement. This 0.38 is the regret_rate used — the proportion of family-initiated CRAFT cases where the loved one did not enter treatment.
  2. [2] Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment (PMC) — Analyzing Components of Community Reinforcement and Family Training (CRAFT): Is Treatment Entry Training Sufficient?
    Analyzing Components of Community Reinforcement and Family Training (CRAFT): Is Treatment Entry Training Sufficient?
    Статистика
    CRAFT achieved 62% treatment engagement vs 37% in Al-Anon/Nar-Anon Facilitation in a sample of 115 CSOs
    Выдержка
    “"Initial Treatment Entry rates were 62% ( n =24) and 63% ( n =24) in the CRAFT and TEnT conditions, respectively, and 37% ( n =14) in the ANF condition." ”
    Данные источника:
    2017-11-01
    Дата обращения
    2026-05-22
    Расчёт
    RCT, N=115 CSOs randomised to CRAFT (n=39), TEnT (n=38), or Al-/Nar-Anon facilitation (n=38). CRAFT achieved 62% treatment entry. Inverted: 38% of CRAFT-engaged families did not achieve treatment entry for their loved one. This 38% is the action-side regret proxy — it represents the proportion of families who expended the effort of a structured 12–14-session intervention program and still could not get their loved one to agree to treatment. No direct regret measure exists; proxy fully disclosed.

Источники: бездействие

Реестр утверждений

Каждое число ниже — это то, что сообщил источник, с дословной цитатой, на которую мы опирались, и тем, как мы пришли к нашей цифре. Нажмите на ссылку, чтобы проверить самостоятельно.

2/2 источников независимо дословно сверены с указанным источником

  1. [1] International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health (PMC) — Family Members' Help-Seeking Behaviour for Their Relative Who Uses Substances: A Cross-Sectional National Study in Brazil Проверено
    Family Members' Help-Seeking Behaviour for Their Relative Who Uses Substances: A Cross-Sectional National Study in Brazil
    Статистика
    66.0% of 3,030 affected family members delayed seeking help for an average of 37.2 months; primary barrier was relative refusing help (31.5%)
    Выдержка
    “"Two-thirds of the participants delayed seeking help for the relative after discovering the substance use problem ( N = 1915; 66.0%). On average, it took 37.16 (SD 70.71) months (approximately 3 years) for the AFM to seek this help. The main reasons for delaying seeking help included the relative not accepting help (31.5%) and participants thinking that help/treatment was not needed (24.0%), along with a lack of knowledge about where to access care (20.6%)." ”
    Данные источника:
    2024-06-01
    Дата обращения
    2026-05-22
    Проверка
    Выдержка независимо повторно загружена и подтверждена слово в слово по указанному источнику в ходе нашей проверки достоверности.
    Расчёт
    Cross-sectional national study, N=3,030 affected family members (AFMs) in Brazil, data collected June 2012–July 2013. Among AFMs who eventually sought help, 66.0% delayed doing so for an average of 37.2 months. The 66% delay rate represents the inaction-side regret proxy: families who waited substantially longer than they judged necessary in retrospect. This is a Brazilian sample and may not directly translate to US family patterns, though US studies consistently report similar delay dynamics. The 0.67 regret_rate rounds the 66.0% figure. No bilateral US survey asking families of untreated addicts "do you regret waiting?" has been published; this delay rate is the closest published analogue. `proxy_only: true` is set.
  2. [2] Journal of Family Medicine and Primary Care (PMC) — Latent by-product of substance use: Burden of care Проверено
    Latent by-product of substance use: Burden of care
    Статистика
    88.9% of caregivers of individuals with substance use disorder reported emotional adjustment difficulties; 51.9% had major depressive disorder
    Выдержка
    “"emotional adjustment 88.9% … Major depressive disorder was identified in 51.9% of the caregivers." ”
    Данные источника:
    2022-08-01
    Дата обращения
    2026-05-22
    Проверка
    Выдержка независимо повторно загружена и подтверждена слово в слово по указанному источнику в ходе нашей проверки достоверности.
    Расчёт
    Study of caregivers of individuals with substance use disorder (SUD). 88.9% reported emotional adjustment difficulties and 51.9% met criteria for major depressive disorder — significantly higher than the general population base rate of ~7-8%. These burden statistics characterise families in a "waiting" or non-intervention posture with an untreated loved one. The emotional burden (88.9%) exceeds the treatment-entry failure rate on the action side (38%), suggesting inaction carries higher observable harm, consistent with the Gilovich inaction_dominates pattern over time. The 51.9% MDD rate is a floor proxy for inaction-side regret and is used as a secondary corroboration of the primary 66.0% delay-regret proxy.

Оговорки

Both sides use proxy measures, not direct regret surveys; `proxy_only: true` is set. The action-side rate (38%) is an outcome-failure proxy derived from the CRAFT RCT: the proportion of family members who completed a structured intervention program and still could not engage their loved one in treatment. This is not the same as "regret" — many of these families may have no regret about trying. The inaction-side rate (67%) is a delay proxy from a Brazilian national study (N=3,030); US data are broadly consistent in direction but no equivalent nationally representative US survey on family delay duration and retrospective regret has been published. The caregiver burden statistics (88.9% emotional difficulties, 51.9% MDD) are from a separate sample of caregivers of SUD patients and are used as corroborating evidence of inaction-side harm, not as independent regret rates. The two sides measure different constructs: action-side measures objective intervention failure, inaction-side measures subjective retrospective delay and burden. The regret_delta (-0.29) should be interpreted as directional, not cardinal. Treatment entry per se does not guarantee recovery — the NIAAA notes that treatment dropout and relapse are common, and families who successfully enrolled a loved one may face renewed regret if treatment does not lead to sustained recovery. CRAFT itself shows no between-group differences in family wellbeing outcomes (depression, quality of life) despite higher treatment entry rates, suggesting the act of organising intervention does not by itself reduce family psychological burden.

Исходные данные: /api/decisions.json

Недавно просмотрено на этом устройстве