Оформить заблаговременную директиву сейчас vs. отложить до приближения смерти
Если вы действуете
Оформить заранее распоряжение о лечении сейчас
Прямого измерения нет
Если вы бездействуете
Отложить оформление распоряжения о лечении
30%
Хотя бы одно число является косвенной оценкой, а не измеренной долей сожалеющих. Как получено каждое число, описано ниже.
Здоровье
Последнее обновление 2026-05-04
Качество доказательств 4.0/5
Оценка по восьми измерениям согласно
рубрике качества
. Каждое измерение оценивается от 1 до 5.
D1 Проверка источников
4/5
D2 Авторитетность и независимость источника
4/5
D3 Точность уровня сожаления
3/5
D4 Сопоставимость источников
3/5
D5 Шаблон Гиловича
5/5
D6 Качество текста
5/5
D7 Полнота оговорок
4/5
D8 Качество выборки
4/5
Среднее4.0/5
Косвенные данные: по этому решению хотя бы один показатель получен из косвенной меры, такой как последствия, удовлетворённость или намерение, либо из редакционной оценки, а не из прямого опроса о сожалении. В примечаниях к каждой стороне ниже описано, как получен показатель.
Если вы действуете
Оформить заранее распоряжение о лечении сейчас
Прямого измерения нет
Ни один источник не приводит число для этой стороны, поэтому мы его не показываем.
Взрослые США, оформившие прижизненное распоряжение, в различных учреждениях (Health Affairs, данные NEJM)
ретроспективно, без фиксированного периода
Если вы бездействуете
Отложить оформление распоряжения о лечении
30%
У 30% семей пациентов без предварительного планирования медицинской помощи при последующем наблюдении обнаружилась клинически значимая депрессия (против 0% при наличии планирования)
Скорбящие семьи пожилых стационарных пациентов, умерших без планирования помощи в конце жизни (Австралия, сопоставимо с данными США)
в течение 3 месяцев после смерти
Число для каждого выбора (что именно измерено, указано на странице)
Оформить заранее распоряжение о лечении сейчасОтложить оформление распоряжения о лечении
Прямого измерения нет30%
Похожие решения
Семантически близкие решения — та же область, другие компромиссы.
Only about one-third of US adults have completed an advance directive, despite the evidence that having one substantially improves the alignment between what patients want at end of life and what they receive. Silveira and colleagues’ 2010 NEJM analysis of 3,746 decedents in the Health and Retirement Study found that, among incapacitated patients who had a living will requesting limited care, 83.2% received care consistent with that preference; the study measured concordance between documented wishes and care, not regret. The Detering 2010 BMJ randomised trial of advance care planning in 309 elderly hospital inpatients found that, among families of the patients who died, 30% in the no-planning control group showed clinically significant depression versus 0% in the planning group, with similar gaps for anxiety (19% vs 0%) and high PTSD risk (15% vs 0%).
The roughly two-thirds of US adults without any advance directive (36.7% completion in the 2017 Health Affairs review) did not all consciously decide to defer — many simply never got around to it. The legal infrastructure for advance directives in the US involves 50 different state forms with varying requirements for witnesses, notarization, and scope; completing an AD in one state and dying in another creates enforcement uncertainty. The evidence on when advance directives are consulted and followed is also imperfect: documents that exist in filing cabinets but not in electronic health records have limited practical effect. The completion decision and the accessibility decision are not the same.
The Detering RCT’s setting — elderly hospital inpatients in Australia, median age in the mid-80s — is different from middle-age preventive ACP completion.
Источники: действие
Реестр утверждений
Каждое число ниже — это то, что сообщил источник, с дословной цитатой, на которую мы опирались, и тем, как мы пришли к нашей цифре. Нажмите на ссылку, чтобы проверить самостоятельно.
1/2 источников независимо дословно сверены с указанным источником
[1]Health Affairs — Approximately One In Three US Adults Completes Any Type Of Advance Directive For End-Of-Life Care
Проверено
Рецензируемая публикация
36.7% of 795,909 people across 150 studies (2011–2016) had completed an advance directive, including 29.3% with living wills; proportions were similar across the years reviewed
Выдержка
“"Among the 795,909 people in the 150 studies we analyzed, 36.7 percent had completed an advance directive, including 29.3 percent with living wills. These proportions were similar across the years reviewed."
”
Данные источника:
2017-08-07
Дата обращения
2026-05-04
Проверка
Выдержка независимо повторно загружена и подтверждена слово в слово по указанному источнику в ходе нашей проверки достоверности.
Расчёт
Yadav et al. 2017 Health Affairs — systematic review of 150 studies (795,909 people). The 36.7% completion rate is the baseline. No published survey directly measures regret among AD completers; the literature frames under-completion (two-thirds of adults have no directive), not over-completion or completer regret, as the problem. No regret figure is shown for this side: the absence of any documented significant regret in completers supports a direction (completion regret is negligible), not a precise number.
[2]New England Journal of Medicine — Advance Directives and Outcomes of Surrogate Decision Making before Death
Рецензируемая публикация
Of 3,746 decedents, 42.5% required decision making about treatment; among incapacitated subjects with a living will requesting limited care, 83.2% received it; 13.6% of proxies reported problems following the subject's instructions
Выдержка
“"Of 3746 subjects, 42.5% required decision making, of whom 70.3% lacked decision-making capacity and 67.6% of those subjects, in turn, had advance directives. Subjects who had living wills were more likely to want limited care (92.7%) or comfort care (96.2%) than all care possible (1.9%); 83.2% of subjects who requested limited care and 97.1% of subjects who requested comfort care received care consistent with their preferences."
”
Данные источника:
2010-04-01
Дата обращения
2026-05-04
Расчёт
Silveira et al. NEJM 2010 — analysis of 3,746 adults in the HRS cohort who died between 2000–2006. This study measured concordance between documented wishes and care received (83.2% of living-will completers wanting limited care got it), and that 13.6% of proxies reported problems following instructions. It did NOT measure family regret or distress caused by having an advance directive — so it supports the directional claim that AD completion improves wish-concordant care, not a specific regret rate.
Источники: бездействие
Реестр утверждений
Каждое число ниже — это то, что сообщил источник, с дословной цитатой, на которую мы опирались, и тем, как мы пришли к нашей цифре. Нажмите на ссылку, чтобы проверить самостоятельно.
[1]BMJ — The impact of advance care planning on end of life care in elderly patients: randomised controlled trial↗ ещё 1 запись
Рецензируемая публикация
Among families of patients who died, 30% in the control (no advance care planning) group had clinically significant depression (score >8) vs 0% in the intervention group (P=0.002); anxiety 19% vs 0% (P=0.02); high PTSD risk 15% vs 0% (P=0.03)
Выдержка
“"In the intervention group, family members of patients who died had significantly less stress (intervention 5, control 15; P<0.001), anxiety (intervention 0, control 3; P=0.02), and depression (intervention 0, control 5; P=0.002) than those of the control patients."
”
Данные источника:
2010-03-23
Дата обращения
2026-05-04
Расчёт
Detering et al. BMJ 2010 — RCT of 309 patients 80 years or older admitted to an Australian hospital, with 56 patients dying by 6-month follow-up. Table 3 reports clinically significant outcomes among bereaved families: depression (score >8) 8/27 (30%) control vs 0/29 (0%) intervention, P=0.002; anxiety (>8) 19% vs 0%, P=0.02; high PTSD risk (Impact of Events >30) 15% vs 0%, P=0.03. The ~30% control-group depression rate is used as the inaction-side proxy: bereaved families of those who deferred ACP showed markedly higher distress than those whose relatives completed it. Note: the RCT is in elderly (80+) hospital inpatients, not middle-age preventive completion; the effect may be smaller for deferral at 45 vs 79.
[2]JAMA — Family Perspectives on End-of-Life Care at the Last Place of Care↗ ещё 1 запись
Рецензируемая публикация
Among 1,578 US decedents, about one quarter with pain or dyspnea did not receive adequate treatment, and more than one third of families in institutional settings reported insufficient emotional support vs about one fifth in home hospice
Выдержка
“"About one quarter of all patients with pain or dyspnea did not receive adequate treatment, and one quarter reported concerns with physician communication... More than one third of respondents cared for by a home health agency, nursing home, or hospital reported insufficient emotional support for the patient and/or 1 or more concerns with family emotional support, compared with about one fifth of those receiving home hospice services."
”
Данные источника:
2004-01-01
Дата обращения
2026-05-04
Расчёт
Teno et al. 2004 JAMA — mortality follow-back survey of family members of 1,578 decedents (representing ~1.97 million US deaths from chronic illness in 2000). This paper measures family-reported quality-of-care concerns by setting (undertreated pain, insufficient emotional support, respect), NOT advance directives or regret. It is included as corroborating context that bereaved families frequently report unmet end-of-life care needs — the gap that advance care planning aims to reduce — not as a direct measure of the inaction-side regret rate.
Оговорки
The Detering RCT enrolled hospital inpatients aged 80 or older, with a reported median age of 84 (control) to 85 (intervention) -- not middle-age adults doing preventive ACP completion. The family distress effect may be smaller for deferral at younger ages where the death is further away and less predictable. AD legal frameworks vary substantially by jurisdiction — in the US, 50-state variation in form requirements, scope, and enforceability creates barriers to use even when documents exist. AD completion skews heavily toward white, educated, higher-income adults in the US; the 36.7% national figure masks large disparities. The Silveira 2010 finding that ADs improve care concordance depends on the surrogate and care team actually locating and following the document — an implementation challenge separate from the completion decision. The action side has no direct regret survey.