Аборт или продолжение незапланированной беременности
Если вы действуете
Сделать аборт
5,0%
Если вы бездействуете
Сохранить незапланированную беременность
4,0%
Хотя бы одно число является косвенной оценкой, а не измеренной долей сожалеющих. Как получено каждое число, описано ниже.
Здоровье
Последнее обновление 2026-04-25
Качество доказательств 4.63/5
Оценка по восьми измерениям согласно
рубрике качества
. Каждое измерение оценивается от 1 до 5.
D1 Проверка источников
5/5
D2 Авторитетность и независимость источника
4/5
D3 Точность уровня сожаления
4/5
D4 Сопоставимость источников
4/5
D5 Шаблон Гиловича
5/5
D6 Качество текста
5/5
D7 Полнота оговорок
5/5
D8 Качество выборки
5/5
Среднее4.63/5
Косвенные данные: по этому решению хотя бы один показатель получен из косвенной меры, такой как последствия, удовлетворённость или намерение, либо из редакционной оценки, а не из прямого опроса о сожалении. В примечаниях к каждой стороне ниже описано, как получен показатель.
Если вы действуете
Сделать аборт
5,0%
~5% через пять лет после процедуры
Женщины США, сделавшие желанный аборт на сроке, близком к гестационному пределу
5 лет после процедуры
Если вы бездействуете
Сохранить незапланированную беременность
4,0%
~4% через пять лет — выраженное сожаление о продолжении беременности
Женщины США, которым отказали в аборте и которые доносили беременность (Исследование Turnaway)
5 лет после отказа
Число для каждого выбора (что именно измерено, указано на странице)
Сделать абортСохранить незапланированную беременность
5,0%4,0%
Похожие решения
Семантически близкие решения — та же область, другие компромиссы.
The UCSF Turnaway Study — the largest longitudinal study of abortion
decision outcomes — tracked women from 30 US facilities over five years.
Among those who received an abortion, about 5% did not affirm it was
the right decision at the five-year mark; relief was the predominant
emotion at every time point. Among women denied an abortion who carried
to term, about 4% expressed regret about continuing the pregnancy by the same
five-year mark. The near-symmetry is the headline: both paths converge
on high reported satisfaction.
This finding challenges narratives on both sides of the debate. The
claim that abortion leads to lasting regret is not supported — roughly
5% of women did not affirm the decision, and even that figure includes
ambivalence rather than outright regret. Equally, the claim that women
forced to continue unwanted pregnancies will resent the outcome is not
borne out at the five-year horizon — roughly 4% report not being glad
they kept the child, and most adapted with declining distress over time. The emotional trajectory matters: initial
distress among turnaways was substantial (sadness, anger, anxiety in the
weeks after denial), but it declined steadily.
The caveat that dominates is selection. The turnaway group did not choose
to continue — they were denied by gestational-limit policies. This
quasi-natural experiment is the study’s methodological strength but means
the “inaction” side represents forced continuation, not a deliberate
preference. Attrition was also significant: 38% of the turnaway cohort
was lost by year five, and those who stayed may have been those who
adapted best. The emotional picture is more complex than a single
satisfaction item suggests — significant minorities reported mixed
feelings even while affirming the decision was right.
Источники: действие
Реестр утверждений
Каждое число ниже — это то, что сообщил источник, с дословной цитатой, на которую мы опирались, и тем, как мы пришли к нашей цифре. Нажмите на ссылку, чтобы проверить самостоятельно.
[1]Social Science & Medicine / Rocca et al. — Decision rightness and relief predominate over the years following an abortion
Рецензируемая публикация
At 5 years, 95% of women who obtained an abortion reported it was the right decision
Выдержка
“"women were overwhemingly sure of their decision: 95% felt their decision was the right one at each assessment after their abortion, and the predicted probability of abortion being the right decision was 99% at 5 years afterwards."
”
Данные источника:
2020-01-01
Дата обращения
2026-04-25
Расчёт
The Turnaway Study followed women from 30 US facilities over 5 years. The 95% "right decision" figure at 5 years implies ~5% did not affirm it was right, which is the upper bound for regret. We use 0.05 as the regret_rate.
[2]UC San Francisco — Five Years After Abortion, Nearly All Women Say It Was the Right Decision, Study Finds
Авторитетный справочник
More than 95% of participants reported that abortion was the right decision over five years of follow-up
Выдержка
“"More than 95 percent of participants reported that having the abortion was the right decision for them over five years of follow-up. Feelings of relief and happiness increased over time, while negative emotions declined."
”
Данные источника:
2020-01-12
Дата обращения
2026-04-25
Расчёт
Press summary of the Rocca et al. peer-reviewed paper. Corroborates the 95% figure and adds that positive emotions increased over time while negative emotions diminished.
Источники: бездействие
Реестр утверждений
Каждое число ниже — это то, что сообщил источник, с дословной цитатой, на которую мы опирались, и тем, как мы пришли к нашей цифре. Нажмите на ссылку, чтобы проверить самостоятельно.
[1]ANSIRH / University of California, San Francisco — The Turnaway Study↗ ещё 1 запись
Первичное исследование
By 5 years, 96% of women who were denied an abortion and carried to term said they were glad they kept the baby
Выдержка
“"By five years after being denied an abortion, 96% of women turned away indicated they were glad they had kept their pregnancies."
”
Данные источника:
2022-06-15
Дата обращения
2026-04-25
Расчёт
The Turnaway Study's "turnaways" who carried to term form the inaction group. 96% glad implies ~4% not glad, used as the regret_rate. Note the smaller sample (n≈161 who gave birth) and the selection effect: women denied abortion who then chose adoption are excluded from this figure.
[2]Social Science & Medicine / Foster et al. — Emotions over five years after denial of abortion in the United States
Рецензируемая публикация
Women denied abortion who gave birth showed initial distress that declined over 5 years; by 5 years most reported positive feelings about the child
Выдержка
“"Emotions became significantly less negative and more positive over their pregnancy and after childbirth."
”
Данные источника:
2020-12-01
Дата обращения
2026-04-25
Расчёт
Longitudinal emotion tracking for the denial group. Confirms that initial distress fades and most women adapt positively, consistent with the 96% "glad" figure from the main Turnaway summary.
Оговорки
The two populations are not interchangeable: women who obtained an abortion self-selected into that decision, while the "turnaways" were denied by gestational-limit policies — they did not freely choose to continue. This quasi-natural experiment is the study's strength but also limits generalizability. The Turnaway Study has been criticized for attrition (38% of the turnaway group was lost to follow-up by year 5) and for the potential that women who adapted well were more likely to remain in the study. Emotional complexity is not captured by a single "right decision" item: 33-41% of women who had abortions reported some regret alongside affirming it was right, and initial distress among turnaways was substantial. The near-symmetry of the 5-year outcome (95% vs 96% "right decision") is itself a finding — both paths lead to high reported satisfaction.