Грудное вскармливание или искусственное вскармливание ребёнка
Если вы действуете
Грудное вскармливание
15%
Если вы бездействуете
Кормление смесью
67%
Хотя бы одно число является косвенной оценкой, а не измеренной долей сожалеющих. Как получено каждое число, описано ниже.
Семья
Последнее обновление 2026-04-26
Качество доказательств 4.38/5
Оценка по восьми измерениям согласно
рубрике качества
. Каждое измерение оценивается от 1 до 5.
D1 Проверка источников
5/5
D2 Авторитетность и независимость источника
5/5
D3 Точность уровня сожаления
2/5
D4 Сопоставимость источников
4/5
D5 Шаблон Гиловича
5/5
D6 Качество текста
5/5
D7 Полнота оговорок
5/5
D8 Качество выборки
4/5
Среднее4.38/5
Косвенные данные: по этому решению хотя бы один показатель получен из косвенной меры, такой как последствия, удовлетворённость или намерение, либо из редакционной оценки, а не из прямого опроса о сожалении. В примечаниях к каждой стороне ниже описано, как получен показатель.
Если вы действуете
Грудное вскармливание
15%
15% кормящих матерей сообщают о чувстве вины из-за метода кормления (приближение через вину)
Матери младенцев ≤26 недель, начавшие грудное вскармливание, набраны через соцсети (международно, преимущественно Великобритания)
ретроспективно, младенцы до 26 недель
Если вы бездействуете
Кормление смесью
67%
67% матерей на смеси сообщают о чувстве вины из-за метода кормления (приближение через вину)
Матери младенцев ≤26 недель, использующие смесь в любом количестве, набраны через соцсети (международно, преимущественно Великобритания)
ретроспективно, младенцы до 26 недель
Число для каждого выбора (что именно измерено, указано на странице)
Грудное вскармливаниеКормление смесью
15%67%
Похожие решения
Семантически близкие решения — та же область, другие компромиссы.
67% of formula-feeding mothers report guilt about their feeding method,
compared with only 15% of breastfeeding mothers — a 4.5:1 ratio that makes
infant feeding one of the sharpest guilt asymmetries in parenting research.
Both figures come from companion studies by Fallon et al. at the University of
Liverpool, using identical methodology on comparable populations (845
breastfeeding and 601 formula-feeding mothers with infants under six months).
A 2021 systematic review of 20 studies by Jackson et al. confirmed the
directional finding: formula feeders consistently report more guilt than
breastfeeders across multiple countries and study designs. Russell et al.
(2021) independently replicated the pattern in two UK samples, finding that
guilt — but not shame — was elevated among formula feeders and predicted
shorter breastfeeding duration.
The asymmetry is partly an artifact of public health framing. Decades of
“breast is best” messaging created a norm against which formula feeding
registers as a deviation, and deviations attract guilt. Fallon’s data show
that guilt among formula feeders is more internally motivated (30%) than
externally imposed (12%), though most mothers (55%) experienced both — a
pattern consistent with internalized stigma rather than direct shaming. Among
breastfeeders, the smaller guilt load still spikes among mothers who supplement
with formula, suggesting that any departure from exclusive breastfeeding
triggers the same normative penalty.
The critical caveat is that these figures measure guilt, not classical
retrospective regret. Guilt is a proximal emotional response (“I feel bad
about this choice”) rather than a considered counterfactual judgment (“I wish
I had chosen differently”). Mothers who chose formula from the outset report
substantially less guilt than those who intended to breastfeed but could not
sustain it. The 67% average conflates deliberate choosers with reluctant
switchers, and the latter subgroup drives much of the guilt signal. This
means the asymmetry is less about formula itself and more about unmet
expectations — a distinction that matters for anyone trying to read these
numbers as guidance rather than just measurement.
Источники: действие
Реестр утверждений
Каждое число ниже — это то, что сообщил источник, с дословной цитатой, на которую мы опирались, и тем, как мы пришли к нашей цифре. Нажмите на ссылку, чтобы проверить самостоятельно.
1/2 источников независимо дословно сверены с указанным источником
[1]Maternal & Child Nutrition (Fallon et al.) — Differences in the emotional and practical experiences of exclusively breastfeeding and combination feeding mothers
Проверено
Рецензируемая публикация
15% of breastfeeding mothers reported feeling guilty about their feeding method
Выдержка
“"In the overall sample, 15% of the mothers reported feeling guilty, 38% stigmatized, and 55% felt the need to defend their feeding choice."
”
Данные источника:
2016-10-03
Дата обращения
2026-04-26
Проверка
Выдержка независимо повторно загружена и подтверждена слово в слово по указанному источнику в ходе нашей проверки достоверности.
Расчёт
Fallon et al. (2016) surveyed 845 mothers with infants ≤26 weeks who had initiated breastfeeding. 15% of the total breastfeeding sample reported guilt. The study included both exclusively breastfeeding and combination-feeding mothers; guilt rates were higher among combination feeders. We use the overall 15% as the action-side rate.
[2]Journal of Applied Social Psychology (Russell et al.) — Infant feeding and internalized stigma: The role of guilt and shame
Рецензируемая публикация
Women who breastfed and women who formula-fed experienced similar levels of shame; guilt uniquely predicted shorter exclusive breastfeeding duration
Выдержка
“Women who bottle-fed experienced more guilt, and guilt, but not shame, was related to whether women had the desire to carry on breastfeeding. Higher self-efficacy predicted lower internalized stigma of feeding choice. Women who breastfed and women who formula-fed experienced similar levels of shame.
”
Данные источника:
2021-07-01
Дата обращения
2026-04-26
Расчёт
Russell et al. (2021) Study 1 (N=160) and Study 2 (N=118) examined guilt and shame across feeding methods. Confirms that guilt is present but lower among breastfeeders than formula feeders, and that the guilt construct is distinct from regret. Independent of the Fallon et al. Liverpool team.
Источники: бездействие
Реестр утверждений
Каждое число ниже — это то, что сообщил источник, с дословной цитатой, на которую мы опирались, и тем, как мы пришли к нашей цифре. Нажмите на ссылку, чтобы проверить самостоятельно.
[1]Maternal & Child Nutrition (Fallon et al.) — The emotional and practical experiences of formula-feeding mothers
Рецензируемая публикация
67% of formula-feeding mothers reported feeling guilty about their feeding method; 68% felt stigmatized; 76% felt the need to defend their choice
Выдержка
“Of the 601 mothers, the majority experienced feelings of guilt (67%) about their choice of feeding method. Guilt was more likely to be internally motivated (30%) than stem from external sources (12%), although many experienced it from both channels (55%). Additionally, 68% felt stigmatized and 76% felt the need to defend their feeding choice.
”
Данные источника:
2017-01-09
Дата обращения
2026-04-26
Расчёт
Fallon et al. (2017) recruited 890 formula-feeding mothers via social media; 601 completed the full survey. 67% of completers reported guilt. This is the companion paper to the breastfeeding study (Fallon et al. 2016) using the same methodology, making the two rates directly comparable.
[2]Maternal & Child Nutrition (Jackson et al.) — Guilt, shame, and postpartum infant feeding outcomes: A systematic review
Рецензируемая публикация
Systematic review of 20 studies confirmed formula feeders experienced guilt more commonly than breastfeeding mothers
Выдержка
“"The study selection process identified 20 articles, published between 1997 and 2017. Quantitative results demonstrated formula feeders experienced guilt more commonly than breastfeeding mothers."
”
Данные источника:
2021-05-01
Дата обращения
2026-04-26
Расчёт
Jackson et al. (2021) systematic review of 20 studies (1997–2017). Confirms the directional finding that formula feeders experience guilt at higher rates than breastfeeders. Does not provide a single pooled estimate but corroborates the Fallon et al. figures.
Оговорки
Both rates measure guilt, not regret per se — guilt is a related but distinct construct. The "(guilt proxy)" label in regret_display flags this explicitly. Both studies used convenience samples recruited via social media, skewing toward engaged, internet-active mothers in the UK and similar Western countries. The 67% formula-feeding figure likely captures guilt amplified by pro-breastfeeding public health messaging (the "breast is best" norm); in populations with weaker breastfeeding promotion, the gap would almost certainly narrow. Mothers who formula-fed by choice from the start reported less guilt than those who switched after failed breastfeeding attempts, so the 67% average obscures meaningful within-group variation. Russell et al. (2021) confirmed that guilt is more salient for formula feeders than breastfeeders across independent UK samples. The 4.5:1 ratio is directionally robust but should not be read as a universal constant.