Lewati ke konten
Likelier

Bertindak vs. tidak bertindak: angka untuk tiap pilihan

Memilih kedokteran di bawah tekanan orang tua vs. mengikuti jalur karier sendiri di India

Jika Anda bertindak

Memilih MBBS karena tekanan orang tua

39%

Jika Anda tidak bertindak

Mengikuti jalur karier sendiri

Tidak ada pengukuran langsung

Setidaknya satu angka adalah perkiraan tidak langsung, bukan tingkat penyesalan yang diukur. Cara setiap angka diperoleh dijelaskan di bawah.


Career

Terakhir ditinjau 2026-05-13

Kualitas bukti 3.63/5

Skor tinjauan delapan dimensi terhadap rubrik kualitas . Setiap dimensi dinilai 1–5.

D1 Verifikasi sumber
4/5
D2 Otoritas & independensi sumber
4/5
D3 Akurasi tingkat penyesalan
3/5
D4 Keterbandingan sumber
2/5
D5 Pola Gilovich
5/5
D6 Kualitas prosa
4/5
D7 Kelengkapan peringatan
4/5
D8 Kualitas sampel
3/5
Rata-rata 3.63/5
A medical textbook open beside a sketchpad and a camera, a fork in a corridor behind them.
Data tidak langsung: untuk keputusan ini, setidaknya satu angka berasal dari ukuran tidak langsung, seperti dampak, kepuasan, atau niat, atau dari perkiraan redaksi, bukan dari survei yang menanyakan penyesalan secara langsung. Catatan untuk tiap pilihan di bawah menjelaskan bagaimana angkanya diperoleh.

Jika Anda bertindak

Memilih MBBS karena tekanan orang tua

39%

39% mahasiswa MBBS tahun pertama menyesali memilih kedokteran

Mahasiswa MBBS tahun pertama di Telangana, India

lintas-bagian, 2018

Jika Anda tidak bertindak

Mengikuti jalur karier sendiri

Tidak ada pengukuran langsung

Tidak ada sumber yang menyebut angka untuk sisi ini, jadi kami tidak menampilkan angka.

Lulusan India yang memilih jalur non-MBBS/non-teknik

lintas-bagian, 2019-2023

Angka untuk tiap pilihan (ukurannya disebut di halaman)

Keputusan terkait

Keputusan yang serupa secara semantik — area yang sama, kompromi yang berbeda.

career

Jurusan kuliah

Angka untuk tiap pilihan (ukurannya disebut di halaman)

career

China: terima gaokao vs. ulang ujian

Angka untuk tiap pilihan (ukurannya disebut di halaman)

lifestyle

India: emigrasi vs. tetap tinggal

Angka untuk tiap pilihan (ukurannya disebut di halaman)

career

Ganti karier

% menyesal dengan pilihan ini

Ketidakaktifan mendominasi

Penyesalan tidak bertindak 1.5× lebih tinggi

career

Korea: layanan sipil vs. sektor swasta

Angka untuk tiap pilihan (ukurannya disebut di halaman)

lifestyle

Gap year vs. langsung ke universitas

Angka untuk tiap pilihan (ukurannya disebut di halaman)

career

Putus kuliah vs. selesaikan gelar

Angka untuk tiap pilihan (ukurannya disebut di halaman)

career

Keputusan kuliah

Angka untuk tiap pilihan (ukurannya disebut di halaman)

Career regret rates among Indian medical students are among the better- documented in the developing world. A cross-sectional study of 150 first-year MBBS students in Telangana found that 39.33% reported regret about their career choice, with the demanding nature of lifelong medical study cited by 61% of those who regretted. A parallel study in Andhra Pradesh found approximately 33%, placing the Telangana figure within a nationally plausible range. Contextually, a 2023 cross-sectional survey of 570 adolescents in Karnataka found that 87% reported high perceived parental academic pressure related to competitive entrance examinations. These figures describe a system in which career selection is frequently a family-level rather than an individual decision, with regret emerging post-enrolment when the reality of the training diverges from expectations.

For those who pursue alternate paths, no direct regret survey of non-medicine choosers exists. A 2025 UN-sponsored survey of 21,239 Indian students (grades 9-12) found that only about 10% reported receiving professional career guidance before choosing a degree path. The near-total absence of structured guidance means that deviating from the medicine/engineering track often happens without actionable information. NASSCOM data reported by The Logical Indian places only about a quarter of Indian engineering graduates as quality/employable (and barely ~2.5 lakh of ~15 lakh annual graduates secure core-industry jobs), demonstrating that the socially prescribed alternative (engineering, when not medicine) carries its own substantial failure rate. There is therefore no measured regret figure for this side, and none is shown.

Important caveats apply. The MBBS regret rate is from a single regional sample, and the inaction side has no direct measurement, so no gap between the two sides is measured. Social- desirability bias is also significant, as students surveyed in institutional settings may underreport regret about a choice their family made for them. The economic value of medicine varies sharply by specialisation, meaning regret rates likely differ substantially between rural generalists and urban surgeons.

Sumber: tindakan

Buku besar klaim

Setiap angka di bawah ini adalah apa yang dilaporkan masing-masing sumber, dengan kutipan kata demi kata yang kami andalkan dan bagaimana kami sampai pada angka kami. Klik tautan mana saja untuk memverifikasi langsung.

1/2 sumber diverifikasi secara independen kata demi kata terhadap sumber terkutip

  1. [1] Indian Journal of Community Medicine and Public Health — Career choice regrets among first year MBBS students: A cross-sectional study
    Career choice regrets among first year MBBS students: A cross-sectional study
    Statistik
    39.33% of first-year MBBS students reported career-choice regret; top reason was demanding nature of study (61%)
    Kutipan
    “"59 (39.33%) out of 150 subjects were having regret feeling for choosing medical profession … Out of 59 students who regret for joining in MBBS, 36 (61.01%) reported lifelong reading was the main reason for having regrets" ”
    Data sumber dari
    2018-01-01
    Diakses
    2026-05-13
    Perhitungan
    The 39.33% figure is taken directly from the study's reported prevalence of career-choice regret among n=150 first-year MBBS students. A parallel study in Andhra Pradesh found ~33%, placing the Telangana figure within a plausible national range. We use 0.39 as the action-regret rate.
  2. [2] PubMed Central — Academic stress, perceived parental pressure, and anxiety related to competitive entrance examinations and the general well-being among adolescents – A cross-sectional survey from Karnataka, India Terverifikasi
    Academic stress, perceived parental pressure, and anxiety related to competitive entrance examinations and the general well-being among adolescents – A cross-sectional survey from Karnataka, India
    Statistik
    87% of surveyed adolescents (496 of 570) reported high perceived parental academic pressure related to competitive entrance examinations
    Kutipan
    “"Most of the adolescents, 496 (87.0%), have experienced high perceived parental academic pressure related to competitive entrance examinations, … The majority of the adolescents, 490 (86.0%), have experienced high academic stress related to competitive entrance examinations," ”
    Data sumber dari
    2023-08-01
    Diakses
    2026-06-30
    Verifikasi
    Kutipan diambil ulang secara independen dan dikonfirmasi kata demi kata terhadap sumber terkutip selama audit pendasaran kami.
    Perhitungan
    The 87% parental-pressure figure establishes the structural context in which medicine is often chosen. It does not directly measure regret but supports the mechanistic link between external pressure and post-enrolment regret documented in the IJCMPH study.

Sumber: tidak bertindak

Buku besar klaim

Setiap angka di bawah ini adalah apa yang dilaporkan masing-masing sumber, dengan kutipan kata demi kata yang kami andalkan dan bagaimana kami sampai pada angka kami. Klik tautan mana saja untuk memverifikasi langsung.

2/2 sumber diverifikasi secara independen kata demi kata terhadap sumber terkutip

  1. [1] ETV Bharat (reporting a UN-sponsored career-aspirations survey of 21,239 students) — Only 10% of Indian students receive career guidance Terverifikasi
    Only 10% of Indian students receive career guidance
    Statistik
    About 10% of Indian students (grades 9-12) report receiving professional career guidance before choosing a degree path
    Kutipan
    “"Only 10.4% of students reported having professional guidance … “Without professional guidance, students chase secure employment or trendy professions instead of exploring what truly suits their aptitude,”" ”
    Data sumber dari
    2025-09-29
    Diakses
    2026-06-30
    Verifikasi
    Kutipan diambil ulang secara independen dan dikonfirmasi kata demi kata terhadap sumber terkutip selama audit pendasaran kami.
    Perhitungan
    With only ~10% of students receiving professional career guidance, roughly nine in ten who deviate from the socially prescribed medicine/engineering path do so without structured information, creating a distinct pathway for post-choice uncertainty about reduced income or status. This source measures guidance prevalence, NOT regret; no inaction-regret figure is shown, because there is no direct survey of non-medicine choosers.
  2. [2] The Logical Indian (reporting NASSCOM data) — NASSCOM Points At Failing Education System For Huge Employability Gap Terverifikasi
    NASSCOM Points At Failing Education System For Huge Employability Gap
    Statistik
    Only ~25% of Indian engineering graduates are quality/employable; of ~15 lakh annual graduates barely ~2.5 lakh (≈17%) secure core-industry jobs
    Kutipan
    “"Engineering colleges in India are churning out only 25 percent quality engineers, and nearly 80-85 percent of youngsters are not suitably trained for any job. … India produces around 15 lakh engineering graduates every year, of which barely 2.5 lakhs of them succeed in getting jobs in the core engineering industry." ”
    Data sumber dari
    2023-03-04
    Diakses
    2026-06-30
    Verifikasi
    Kutipan diambil ulang secara independen dan dikonfirmasi kata demi kata terhadap sumber terkutip selama audit pendasaran kami.
    Perhitungan
    The roughly 80% non-employability rate for engineering graduates demonstrates that the "expected path" (MBBS or engineering) also carries substantial failure risk. This moderates the inaction-regret rate: choosing an alternate path does not guarantee worse outcomes, since the prescribed path has its own high failure rate. This source measures graduate employability, NOT regret. No inaction-regret figure is shown, because there is no direct survey of the share who experience reduced social status or economic outcomes relative to peer expectations after deviating from medicine.

Catatan

Angka 39,33% berasal dari satu studi regional (n=150, Telangana) dan mungkin tidak mewakili semua mahasiswa kedokteran India secara nasional. Studi paralel Andhra Pradesh menemukan sekitar 33%. Sisi non-tindakan tidak memiliki pengukuran langsung: tidak ada survei terhadap mahasiswa yang memilih jalur non-kedokteran, dan literatur hasil-karier dan kesenjangan-bimbingan hanyalah proksinya. Bias keinginan sosial signifikan dalam konteks India: mahasiswa yang memilih kedokteran di bawah tekanan orang tua mungkin di bawah-laporan penyesalan jika disurvei dalam pengaturan kelembagaan. Kalkulus ekonomi berubah secara substansial berdasarkan spesialisasi: dokter umum dan dokter pedesaan menghasilkan jauh lebih sedikit daripada ahli bedah kota atau spesialis.

Data mentah: /api/decisions.json

Baru-baru ini dilihat di perangkat ini