Scegliere un mutuo a tasso fisso versus un mutuo a tasso variabile
Se agisci
Mutuo a tasso variabile
43%
Se non agisci
Mutuo a tasso fisso
Nessuna misurazione diretta
Almeno una cifra è una stima indiretta, non un tasso di rimpianto misurato. Come è stata ottenuta ogni cifra è spiegato più sotto.
Finanza
Ultima revisione 2026-05-13
Qualità delle prove 3.88/5
Punteggio di revisione su otto dimensioni rispetto alla
griglia di qualità
. Ogni dimensione valutata da 1 a 5.
D1 Verifica delle fonti
4/5
D2 Autorità e indipendenza delle fonti
3/5
D3 Precisione del tasso di rimpianto
3/5
D4 Comparabilità delle fonti
2/5
D5 Schema di Gilovich
5/5
D6 Qualità della prosa
5/5
D7 Completezza degli avvertimenti
5/5
D8 Qualità del campione
4/5
Media3.88/5
Dati indiretti: per questa decisione almeno una cifra deriva da una misura indiretta, come esiti, soddisfazione o intenzione, oppure da una stima della redazione, e non da un'indagine che chieda direttamente del rimpianto. Le note di ciascuna opzione, più sotto, spiegano come è stata ottenuta la cifra.
Se agisci
Mutuo a tasso variabile
43%
Il 43% dei mutuatari ARM si pente di aver scelto un mutuo a tasso variabile
Proprietari di case statunitensi con un mutuo a tasso variabile, panel online
intervistato a dicembre 2022, dopo l'inizio degli aumenti dei tassi della Federal Reserve
Se non agisci
Mutuo a tasso fisso
Nessuna misurazione diretta
Nessuna fonte indica un dato per questo lato, quindi non ne mostriamo.
Proprietari di case statunitensi, campione online rappresentativo a livello nazionale
intervistato ad aprile 2025
Cifra per ciascuna scelta (la misura è indicata nella pagina)
Mutuo a tasso variabileMutuo a tasso fisso
43%Nessuna misurazione diretta
Decisioni correlate
Decisioni semanticamente simili — stesso terreno, compromessi diversi.
Cifra per ciascuna scelta (la misura è indicata nella pagina)
Accendere il prestito-anticipo (payday loan)Rinunciare al prestito
37%81%
Forty-three percent of US homeowners with an adjustable-rate mortgage reported regretting their choice in a December 2022 survey of 1,203 ARM holders conducted by PureSpectrum for U.S. News & World Report, the larger and earlier-fielded of the two ARM-regret surveys cited here. The primary driver, cited by 44% of regretters, was that their interest rate had adjusted to a higher level than they anticipated. A follow-up survey by Point in January 2024, drawing on 332 ARM holders, placed the regret rate at 70%, consistent with the pattern of escalating regret as further Federal Reserve rate increases pushed variable payments well above their initial levels. By contrast, no survey measures regret among fixed-rate holders as such: Bankrate’s 2025 general homeowner survey (n=1,363) did not separate borrowers by mortgage type, so the fixed-rate side has no direct measurement.
The evidence base is asymmetric. Both ARM surveys asked a direct regret question to ARM holders specifically; the fixed-rate side has no direct measurement. No published study has asked matched samples of ARM and fixed-rate borrowers the same regret question in the same instrument. What the surveys do show is that the ARM regret rate climbed from 43% to 70% between the two survey waves as the rate environment deteriorated. In the US context, the fixed-rate mortgage is taken here to be the dominant default (an assumption; no source listed gives the share), so choosing an ARM represents an active deviation from that default, a bet that rates would stay low.
The survey timing matters for interpretation. Both ARM surveys were fielded during or shortly after a historically rapid rate-tightening cycle (2022-2023), creating a period of maximum regret exposure. ARM regret in a falling-rate environment would likely be far lower, since resets would land at or below the initial rate rather than well above it. The 43% figure (the more conservative primary estimate) is a rate-cycle-specific snapshot, not a structural truth about the product. What is structural is the uncertainty asymmetry: fixed-rate borrowers know their payment in advance; ARM borrowers do not. That uncertainty is the proximate cause of regret in both surveys, not the product category per se.
Fonti: azione
Registro delle fonti
Ogni numero qui sotto è ciò che ciascuna fonte ha riportato, con la citazione testuale su cui ci siamo basati e come siamo arrivati alla nostra cifra. Clicca su qualsiasi link per verificare direttamente.
[1]U.S. News & World Report / PureSpectrum — ARM Borrowers Gamble Short-Term Savings on Long-Term Risk
Studio primario
43% of ARM borrowers regret choosing an adjustable-rate mortgage; the most common reason was that their interest rate adjusted to a higher rate than expected (44% of regretters)
Estratto
“"Forty-three percent of survey respondents regret choosing an ARM. Among them, the most common reason was that their interest rate adjusted to a higher rate than expected (44%)."
”
Dati originali da
2022-12-20
Consultato
2026-05-13
Calcolo
U.S. News & World Report commissioned PureSpectrum to conduct a nationwide online survey of 1,203 homeowners who currently hold an adjustable-rate mortgage, fielded December 14-20, 2022. Only ARM holders participated. The 43% regret rate is a direct self-report and is used here as the action-side regret rate without adjustment. The survey was conducted at the peak of the 2022 Federal Reserve tightening cycle, when the federal funds rate had risen from near-zero to 4.25-4.50% in under 12 months, so the 43% figure reflects rate-hike conditions and may understate regret relative to the longer-run reset exposure faced by 3/1 and 5/1 ARM holders who originated in 2019-2021.
[2]Point / SurveyMonkey — 70% of Homeowners with an Adjustable-Rate Mortgage Regret It
Studio primario
70% of homeowners who have taken out an adjustable-rate mortgage in the past 10 years regret it (January 2024, n=332)
Estratto
“"70% of homeowners with an adjustable-rate mortgage regret it"
”
Dati originali da
2024-01-20
Consultato
2026-05-13
Calcolo
Point (a home equity investment platform) commissioned a SurveyMonkey online panel survey of 332 homeowners who obtained an ARM within the prior 10 years, fielded January 20, 2024. The 70% regret rate is the primary reported finding. The sample is smaller (332) and the platform is an industry participant with a commercial interest in home equity products, so this figure is treated as a corroborating upper-bound estimate rather than the primary rate. The primary rate used in regret_rate is 0.43 (U.S. News/PureSpectrum, n=1,203), which has a larger sample, an independent research firm, and was fielded closer to the moment of rate shock. The Point figure (70%, n=332, 13 months later) is consistent with escalating regret as further rate resets occurred through 2023.
Fonti: inazione
Registro delle fonti
Ogni numero qui sotto è ciò che ciascuna fonte ha riportato, con la citazione testuale su cui ci siamo basati e come siamo arrivati alla nostra cifra. Clicca su qualsiasi link per verificare direttamente.
[1]Bankrate / YouGov — Nearly Half of Homeowners Have at Least One Regret About the Purchase of Their Current Home (Bankrate 2025 Homeowner Regrets Survey)
Studio primario
Among homeowners with at least one regret, 10% regret not getting the best mortgage rate and 16% regret that their mortgage payment is too high; nearly half (45%) of homeowners overall have at least one regret about their home purchase
Estratto
“"Nearly half of current homeowners (45%) say they have at least one regret about the purchase of their current home [...] Among homeowners with some type of regret about the purchase of their current home, buying too small of a house (21%) was the second most common regret after costlier-than-expected maintenance and hidden costs. Other regrets include the mortgage payment being too high (16%), overpaying or paying too much for the house (15%), buying a house in a bad location (14%), buying too big of a house (11%), not getting the best mortgage rate (10%), and not thinking it’s a good investment (6%)."
”
Dati originali da
2025-05-14
Consultato
2026-05-13
Calcolo
Bankrate's 2025 Home Affordability Report surveyed 2,487 adults (1,363 current homeowners) via YouGov online panel (April 2-4, 2025), with demographic quotas for representativeness. The survey did not separately ask fixed-rate vs. ARM holders about their mortgage-type choice; it asked all homeowners about homeownership regrets broadly. No inaction-side regret figure is shown: the survey reports none, and a figure built from it would rest on assumptions. Nearly half (45%) of homeowners report at least one regret; the two mortgage-rate items (payment too high, 16%; not getting the best rate, 10%) are listed as separate items and respondents may have named more than one, so they cannot be added into a share of regretters. No source listed here gives the share of homeowners in the sample who hold fixed-rate loans. No survey directly asks fixed-rate holders whether they regret not choosing an ARM.
[2]National Mortgage News — Adjustable-rate mortgage borrowers express regret over loans
Articolo di cronaca
Approximately 70% of ARM holders say they now regret their choice, driven by interest-rate rises since 2022 to more than two-decade highs (Point survey, January)
Estratto
“"Approximately 70% of ARM holders, including homeowners in both the introductory and variable-rate phase, said they now regret their choice. … The rise of interest rates since 2022 to more than two-decade highs drove the sentiment, as ARM borrowers find a substantially different financial environment today versus the last 10 years,"
”
Dati originali da
2024-01-20
Consultato
2026-05-13
Calcolo
National Mortgage News coverage of the Point (SurveyMonkey) ARM-regret survey fielded in January 2024. Reports the same headline finding as the Point source above (~70% of ARM holders regret their choice), attributing the sentiment to the 2022 onward rate rises. Used here as a second, independent outlet corroborating the elevated ARM-regret level that underpins the action-vs-inaction asymmetry. No independent new data beyond the Point survey it reports.
Avvertenze
Le cifre lato azione e lato inazione non sono tratte da una singola indagine comparativa. Nessuno studio pubblicato ha chiesto a campioni appaiati di mutuatari ARM e a tasso fisso la stessa domanda di rimpianto nella stessa ondata di indagine. Il tasso di rimpianto ARM (43%) proviene da un'indagine limitata esclusivamente ai detentori di ARM (U.S. News/PureSpectrum, dicembre 2022, n=1.203); il lato a tasso fisso non ha una misurazione diretta, solo un'indagine generale sui proprietari di case (Bankrate/YouGov, aprile 2025, n=1.363 proprietari di case) che non ha segmentato per tipo di mutuo. Entrambe le indagini sono state condotte durante un ambiente di tassi elevati (2022-2025), che amplifica il rimpianto ARM. Il tasso di rimpianto ARM è alto in due indagini ARM indipendenti con date di rilevazione e campioni diversi (43% a dicembre 2022; 70% a gennaio 2024), ma non esiste una misurazione comparabile per il tasso fisso. Nel contesto statunitense, il mutuo a tasso fisso è il default dominante (ipotesi di questa voce; nessuna fonte elencata ne indica la quota), quindi scegliere un ARM rappresenta una deviazione attiva — una scommessa che i tassi sarebbero rimasti bassi — rendendo l'ARM il lato azione e il tasso fisso il lato inazione.