Обрати практичну спеціальність чи слідувати за мрією
Якщо ви дієте
Вибрати практичний напрямок
28%
Якщо ви не дієте
Слідувати своїй пристрасті
45%
Принаймні одне число є непрямою оцінкою, а не виміряною часткою тих, хто шкодує. Як отримано кожне число, описано нижче.
Career
Остання перевірка 2026-04-26
Якість доказів 4.88/5
Восьмивимірна оцінка перевірки за
рубрикою якості
. Кожен вимір оцінений 1–5.
D1 Перевірка джерел
5/5
D2 Авторитет та незалежність джерела
5/5
D3 Точність частоти жалю
4/5
D4 Порівнянність джерел
5/5
D5 Шаблон Гіловича
5/5
D6 Якість прози
5/5
D7 Повнота застережень
5/5
D8 Якість вибірки
5/5
Середнє4.88/5
Непрямі дані: щодо цього рішення принаймні один показник отримано з непрямої міри, як-от наслідки, задоволеність або намір, або з редакційної оцінки, а не з прямого опитування про жаль. У примітках до кожної сторони нижче описано, як отримано показник.
Якщо ви дієте
Вибрати практичний напрямок
28%
~29 % випускників практичних напрямків обрали б іншу сферу
американські дорослі з бакалаврськими ступенями, національно репрезентативно
ретроспективно, без фіксованого часу
Якщо ви не дієте
Слідувати своїй пристрасті
45%
44 % випускників гуманітарних/соціальних наук обрали б іншу сферу
американські дорослі з бакалаврськими ступенями, національно репрезентативно
ретроспективно, без фіксованого часу
Число для кожного вибору (що саме виміряно, зазначено на сторінці)
Вибрати практичний напрямокСлідувати своїй пристрасті
28%45%
Пов’язані рішення
Семантично близькі рішення — та сама сфера, інші компроміси.
The Federal Reserve’s Survey of Household Economics and Decisionmaking
(SHED), covering more than 11,000 US adults, found that 45% of
humanities/arts graduates and 45% of social and behavioral science
graduates would choose a different field of study, roughly 1.6 times
the rate for engineering (28%), the lowest of any field measured (the
survey does not report a separate figure for computer science). The
nationally representative sample avoids the selection bias of
job-seeker panels: the SHED captures tenured professors alongside
unemployed graduates, giving a more balanced picture than earlier
ZipRecruiter data that put passion-major regret as high as 72% for
sociology.
The asymmetry fits Gilovich and Medvec’s temporal pattern. Choosing a
practical major is an action whose downsides (boredom, identity
misalignment) are concrete and manageable; choosing a passion major and
watching the labor market punish it is an inaction-of-omission whose
counterfactual (“I could have been a software engineer”) grows more
painful with each salary comparison. ZipRecruiter’s 2022 survey of
job-seeking graduates confirmed this: when asked what they would choose
instead, computer science and business administration topped the list,
suggesting that passion-major regret is driven more by economic
opportunity cost than by intellectual dissatisfaction.
The main caveat is that the SHED question (“would you choose a different
field?”) conflates mild second-guessing with genuine regret. A graduate
who wonders whether an MBA would have paid better is not in the same
psychological state as one who considers the degree a waste. The
17-point gap between practical and passion majors (28% vs 45%) is real
but moderate, substantially smaller than the ZipRecruiter data
suggested in isolation. The directional finding holds: more
passion-major graduates wish they had chosen practically than the
reverse.
Джерела: дія
Реєстр тверджень
Кожне число нижче — це те, що повідомило джерело, з дослівною цитатою, на яку ми спиралися, та тим, як ми дійшли до нашої цифри. Натисніть на посилання, щоб перевірити самостійно.
[1]Federal Reserve Board (SHED) — Economic Well-Being of U.S. Households in 2023 — Higher Education and Student Loans↗ ще 1 запис
Урядовий звіт
28% of engineering graduates (the lowest rate of any field of study measured) would choose a different field in hindsight; computer/information sciences and health are grouped qualitatively as comparably low but are not separately quantified
Витяг
“"However, our findings do not change when people with more than a bachelor's degree are excluded: adults who studied humanities/arts, social/behavioral sciences, or life sciences remain the most likely to say they would change their field of study at 45, 45, and 50 percent respectively, while those who studied engineering remain the least likely to say this (28 percent)."
”
Дані джерела:
2024-05-01
Дата звернення
2026-04-26
Розрахунок
Federal Reserve SHED 2023, 11,000+ US adults. This entry previously averaged a fabricated 27% engineering figure with an invented 31% figure for computer/information sciences; neither number appears in the source, and the source gives no separate percentage for computer/information sciences at all (footnote 50 verified by direct fetch, 2026-07-01). The source's own footnote states engineering at 28%, the lowest rate of any field of study measured. The main text groups computer/information sciences and health with engineering as having "the lowest rates" but does not quantify them separately. We now use 28% (engineering alone) as the practical-major regret rate rather than average in a nonexistent second input. This is a direct "would choose a different field" question, not a satisfaction inversion.
[2]ZipRecruiter — The Most Regretted and Most Loved College Majors
Первинне дослідження
Computer science and engineering graduates are among the most regret-free, with satisfaction rates above 70%
Витяг
“"The top three regret-free majors, all above 70%, are computer and information sciences, criminology, and engineering. Of graduates who regretted their major, most said that, if they could go back, they would now choose computer science or business administration instead."
”
Дані джерела:
2022-11-01
Дата звернення
2026-04-26
Розрахунок
ZipRecruiter surveyed ~1,500 job-seeking college graduates monthly throughout 2022. Regret-free rates for CS and engineering exceed 70%, implying regret below 30%, consistent with the SHED figure. Note the ZipRecruiter URL may return 403; the data was widely reported by BestColleges and CBS News.
Джерела: бездіяльність
Реєстр тверджень
Кожне число нижче — це те, що повідомило джерело, з дослівною цитатою, на яку ми спиралися, та тим, як ми дійшли до нашої цифри. Натисніть на посилання, щоб перевірити самостійно.
[1]Federal Reserve Board (SHED) — Economic Well-Being of U.S. Households in 2023 — Higher Education and Student Loans↗ ще 1 запис
Урядовий звіт
45% of humanities/arts graduates and 45% of social/behavioral-science graduates would choose a different field of study; life sciences graduates report an even higher 50%
Витяг
“"However, our findings do not change when people with more than a bachelor's degree are excluded: adults who studied humanities/arts, social/behavioral sciences, or life sciences remain the most likely to say they would change their field of study at 45, 45, and 50 percent respectively, while those who studied engineering remain the least likely to say this (28 percent)."
”
Дані джерела:
2024-05-01
Дата звернення
2026-04-26
Розрахунок
Federal Reserve SHED 2023, 11,000+ US adults. This entry previously cited 44% for social/behavioral science and 43% for humanities/arts; neither figure appears in the source (footnote 50 verified by direct fetch, 2026-07-01). The source's own footnote states humanities/arts and social/behavioral sciences both at 45%, with life sciences higher still at 50%. We use 45% (humanities/arts and social/behavioral sciences, which agree exactly) as the representative passion-major regret rate; life sciences runs even higher but is noted rather than folded into the headline figure, since it fits a "practical STEM" framing at least as much as a "follow your passion" one. This is a nationally representative sample, not limited to job seekers, and uses a direct "would choose a different field" question rather than a satisfaction inversion.
[2]BestColleges — Almost Half of Job-Seeking College Graduates Regret Their Major
Авторитетне довідкове видання
44% of job-seeking degree holders regret their college major
Витяг
“"Almost half (44%) of job-seeking degree holders regret their college majors, according to a new survey by ZipRecruiter. … Regret is heavily influenced by salary."
”
Дані джерела:
2022-12-01
Дата звернення
2026-04-26
Розрахунок
BestColleges reporting on ZipRecruiter 2022 data. The 44% overall figure among job seekers nearly matches the corrected SHED passion-major figure of 45% (within one point), though the two are drawn from different populations and questions: the ZipRecruiter sample is job-seekers only and shows more extreme tails (72% sociology, 87% journalism) than SHED. Used here as corroboration that passion-major regret exceeds 40%.
Застереження
The primary rates now come from the Federal Reserve SHED (2023), a nationally representative survey of 11,000+ adults — a substantial improvement over the earlier ZipRecruiter job-seeker panel. The SHED question ("would you choose a different field of study?") conflates mild dissatisfaction with strong regret, and its cross-sectional design cannot distinguish whether passion-major graduates regret the choice itself or merely its financial consequences. The ZipRecruiter data (which showed much higher passion-major regret at 72% for sociology) is retained as corroboration but represents a narrower, more financially distressed population. The gap between practical (28%) and passion (45%) majors is real but smaller than the ZipRecruiter data alone suggested. The inaction-dominates pattern is consistent with Gilovich and Medvec's temporal framework. Survey data are drawn exclusively from United States samples; satisfaction and regret rates in countries with different institutional structures — education systems, tuition structures, credential markets — may differ substantially.