There is no direct survey asking Indian stayers and emigrants the same regret question, so both sides here are proxies drawn from the Carnegie Endowment’s 2026 Indian American Attitudes Survey (N=1,000, conducted with YouGov). For the inaction side, the closest available signal is a revealed preference: asked to advise “Rishi,” a hypothetical professional weighing a US work visa against staying in India, 62% recommended applying for the US visa while only 23% advised staying. That endorsement of leaving proxies the perceived opportunity cost of staying — though it is not the same as stayers reporting regret themselves.
On the action side, life abroad carries concrete costs: in the same Carnegie survey, about one in two (50%) Indian Americans reported experiencing discrimination over the prior year, and 14% said they had frequently thought about leaving the US (26% occasionally). The broader diaspora also shows ambivalence — a Heidrick & Struggles / Economic Times study found roughly 82% of Non-Resident Indians would consider returning to India if suitable opportunities arose. None of these is a direct emigration-regret measure, but together they point to substantial unresolved tension with the emigration outcome.
The 12-point gap between these two proxies (inaction 62%, action 50%) should be read cautiously: the two figures measure different constructs — one an advice-to-leave revealed preference, the other a discrimination-experience rate — and are not strictly commensurable. India-specific factors still shape the picture: the NRI identity carries significant social status within Indian culture; destination-country variation is larger for Indian emigrants than for, say, British ones; and the decision is often constrained by family debt, professional networks, and visa rules in ways that blur the line between voluntary choice and structural necessity. The proxy_only flag reflects the absence of a controlled bilateral survey asking the same regret question to emigrants and stayers in the same cohort.







