A June 2021 Hankook Research national survey (n = 1,000 adults aged 18 and over, nationally representative) found that 44% agreed that mandatory military service has more disadvantages than advantages overall, with the rate rising to 62% among those in their 20s who described service as a “waste of time.” This is an attitudinal cost-benefit appraisal across the general adult population, not a retrospective regret question put only to veterans. An event-study analysis of South Korean conscription confirmed objective lasting costs: compulsory military service significantly increased alcohol and tobacco use, with these adverse health effects persisting for years after discharge. The combination of attitudinal negative evaluation (44%) and documented long-lasting physical health costs provides a consistent picture of a substantial action-side downside for standard military service.
The alternative civilian service path, legal only since 30 June 2020, carries its own documented costs. No direct survey of alternative-service completers’ regret or social consequences exists, so the inaction-side rate here is an editorial proxy rather than a measured figure. What is documented is the punitive structural design: the term runs 36 months — twice the 18-21-month active-duty service — and participants are confined to barrack-style lodging inside correctional facilities, a design that the International Center for Law and Religion Studies (BYU) analysis found “has failed to remove the stigma associated with conscientious objectors.” The 15-18 additional months of foregone earnings and career development, the prison-facility confinement, and the residual social stigma all fall on the entire alternative-service population, which remains small and overwhelmingly composed of Jehovah’s Witnesses.
The alternative path has no measured regret rate, so the two paths cannot be compared as regret rates. The South Korean context matters here, since military service has historically been central to male identity and social standing. The action-side rate may understate true regret due to social desirability: admitting that mandatory service was negative in a military-valorising culture carries stigma, and the 44% attitudinal measure likely represents those whose experience was negative enough to overcome that barrier to candid reporting. The inaction side has no direct measurement: no study of alternative-service completers’ regret exists. The alternative service cohort also remains small and concentrated among Jehovah’s Witnesses, so any inaction-side estimate would reflect an unrepresentative early-adopter population rather than the broader population of men who might choose the alternative path if social stigma declines.







