61% of plaintiffs who rejected the defendant’s last settlement offer and proceeded to trial received an equal or worse financial outcome than the offer they turned down, according to Kiser, Asher and McShane’s 2008 analysis of 2,054 California civil cases — the largest empirical study of settlement decision-making errors in the published legal literature. The average cost of that error was $43,100. On the inaction side, the Legal Services Corporation’s 2022 Justice Gap report found that low-income Americans received no or inadequate legal help for 92% of the civil legal problems that substantially impacted their lives — leaving the overwhelming majority of valid legal claims without effective legal action. The data points in opposite directions: the majority of those who fight tend to lose relative to the settlement on the table, and the overwhelming majority of substantial civil legal problems among people without resources go unaddressed.
The asymmetry between plaintiffs and defendants in the Kiser study deserves attention. Defendants made the wrong decision (rejected an offer that turned out better than the judgment) only 24% of the time, compared to 61% for plaintiffs. This gap reflects a systematic pattern: plaintiffs tend to overestimate the strength of their case and underestimate legal costs, while defendants — typically insurance carriers or repeat litigants with actuarial experience — calibrate more accurately. The average defendant error cost was far higher ($1.14 million) when defendants did lose, but the frequency of error was much lower. For most individual plaintiffs who are one-time litigants, the risk is that optimism about court outcomes drives rejection of settlements that would have served them better.
Both proxies measure something real but neither measures regret directly. The 61% outcome-error rate captures financial inferiority, not necessarily felt regret — some plaintiffs pursued litigation for non-financial reasons (vindication, precedent, principle) and may not regret the decision even after losing on the financial metric. The 92% no-or-inadequate-help figure captures the scale of unresolved legal problems among people without resources, not the subjective experience of wishing they had acted. Case type and jurisdiction affect the action-side figures substantially: the Kiser dataset draws from California civil litigation and skews toward personal injury and products liability, which have higher plaintiff error rates than contract or employment disputes. Inheritance disputes, tax challenges, and small claims have structurally different regret dynamics and are not well captured by either source.







