Lewati ke konten
Likelier

Bertindak vs. tidak bertindak: angka untuk tiap pilihan

Menyerahkan anak untuk diadopsi versus memilih untuk membesarkan mereka sendiri

Jika Anda bertindak

Menyerahkan anak untuk diadopsi

38%

Jika Anda tidak bertindak

Membesarkan anak sendiri

8,0%

Setidaknya satu angka adalah perkiraan tidak langsung, bukan tingkat penyesalan yang diukur. Cara setiap angka diperoleh dijelaskan di bawah.


Family

Terakhir ditinjau 2026-05-02

Kualitas bukti 4.25/5

Skor tinjauan delapan dimensi terhadap rubrik kualitas . Setiap dimensi dinilai 1–5.

D1 Verifikasi sumber
5/5
D2 Otoritas & independensi sumber
4/5
D3 Akurasi tingkat penyesalan
3/5
D4 Keterbandingan sumber
3/5
D5 Pola Gilovich
5/5
D6 Kualitas prosa
5/5
D7 Kelengkapan peringatan
5/5
D8 Kualitas sampel
4/5
Rata-rata 4.25/5
A signed document resting beside a small pair of infant shoes on a bare table.
Data tidak langsung: untuk keputusan ini, setidaknya satu angka berasal dari ukuran tidak langsung, seperti dampak, kepuasan, atau niat, atau dari perkiraan redaksi, bukan dari survei yang menanyakan penyesalan secara langsung. Catatan untuk tiap pilihan di bawah menjelaskan bagaimana angkanya diperoleh.

Jika Anda bertindak

Menyerahkan anak untuk diadopsi

38%

38% ibu kandung melaporkan kesedihan substansial pada 6 bulan pasca-penempatan (proksi kesedihan)

Ibu kandung muda yang menempatkan bayi untuk adopsi melalui 30 tempat tinggal kehamilan dan agensi di 13 negara bagian AS

6 bulan pasca-penempatan

Jika Anda tidak bertindak

Membesarkan anak sendiri

8,0%

~7-8% orang tua melaporkan menyesali memiliki anak (penyesalan orang tua umum, proksi terbaik yang tersedia)

Orang tua AS dan Jerman, survei populasi (proksi — tidak ada studi yang secara langsung menyurvei orang tua yang mempertimbangkan relinquishment dan memilih untuk mengasuh)

Lintas-bagian; survei dilakukan di antara orang dewasa AS ≥45 dan orang dewasa Jerman ≥18

Angka untuk tiap pilihan (ukurannya disebut di halaman)

Keputusan terkait

Keputusan yang serupa secara semantik — area yang sama, kompromi yang berbeda.

family

Beritahu vs. sembunyikan adopsi

Tindakan dan tidak bertindak: sumber untuk setiap pilihan

family

Di rumah vs bekerja

Angka untuk tiap pilihan (ukurannya disebut di halaman)

family

Memiliki anak

Angka untuk tiap pilihan (ukurannya disebut di halaman)

family

Panti jompo vs. rawat di rumah

Angka untuk tiap pilihan (ukurannya disebut di halaman)

family

IVF vs. adopsi

Angka untuk tiap pilihan (ukurannya disebut di halaman)

family

Orang tua muda vs. tunda

Angka untuk tiap pilihan (ukurannya disebut di halaman)

family

Metode persalinan

Angka untuk tiap pilihan (ukurannya disebut di halaman)

lifestyle

Pertahankan atau carikan rumah baru hewan

Angka untuk tiap pilihan (ukurannya disebut di halaman)

38% of birth mothers who place an infant for adoption report substantial grief at 6 months post-placement, roughly five times the rate of general parental regret among those who raise their children. Cushman, Kalmuss & Namerow (1993) recorded this in a multistate US sample of 215 young birth mothers, drawn from 30 agencies in 13 states. A further 27% reported “some” grief at the same point.

The grief is often delayed and chronic rather than acute and then resolved. Madden et al. (2018), the most contemporary study, surveyed 223 US birth mothers whose placements were made between 1993 and 2018. Their mean satisfaction with relinquishment was 3.11 on a five-point scale, just above the midpoint. It declined further the more years had passed since placement, so dissatisfaction intensified with time instead of fading. Two variables predicted higher satisfaction: current contact with the adopted child, and full-time employment. Neither is universally available.

Older work reaches back further. Rynearson’s 1982 clinical study, drawn from a small psychiatric sample (n=20), found that only 30% of relinquishing mothers expressed comfort with the adoption. Askren and Bloom’s 1999 review of the broader literature identified chronic grief as a recurring theme in studies from 1978 through 1994.

The parents who considered relinquishment and raised the child instead have almost no dedicated evidence, and that population has never been surveyed directly. The best proxy is general parental regret. Piotrowski (2021, PLOS ONE), synthesizing US and German survey data, estimates that roughly 7–8% of parents would choose not to have children if they could decide again. The Turnaway Study gives a narrower analogue: women denied an abortion who went on to parent reported only 4% regret at five years. Those women had sought abortions, not adoption placements, which limits the comparison. Neither figure captures birth parents who weighed placement and then chose to parent.

The asymmetry supports an action-dominates pattern, in line with Gilovich and Medvec’s framework. Choosing to relinquish produces measurable, persistent grief and dissatisfaction in a substantial minority. Raising a child, even an unintended one, tends toward adaptation and acceptance over time.

The structural confounders are substantial. Coercion history and adoption openness interact powerfully with outcomes. Contemporary voluntary open adoptions with ongoing contact produce substantially better results than the closed adoptions that dominated the 1993 cohort. The 0.38 rate applies to the mixed-era, mixed-openness population it was drawn from. For contemporary voluntary open-adoption placements the true rate is almost certainly lower.

Sumber: tindakan

Buku besar klaim

Setiap angka di bawah ini adalah apa yang dilaporkan masing-masing sumber, dengan kutipan kata demi kata yang kami andalkan dan bagaimana kami sampai pada angka kami. Klik tautan mana saja untuk memverifikasi langsung.

  1. [1] Social Work / Cushman, Kalmuss & Namerow — Placing an Infant for Adoption: The Experiences of Young Birth Mothers
    Placing an Infant for Adoption: The Experiences of Young Birth Mothers
    Statistik
    38% of birth mothers felt 'a lot of grief' at 6 months post-placement; 27% felt 'some' grief (n=215, multistate US)
    Kutipan
    “"At 6 months after placement, 38% of the placer sample reported feeling a lot of grief, and 27% reported feeling some grief. Higher levels of grief were found in birth mothers whose babies went to foster placement prior to adoptive placement. The majority of birth mothers found signing the adoption papers to be one of the most difficult parts of the adoption process." ”
    Data sumber dari
    1993-05-01
    Diakses
    2026-05-02
    Perhitungan
    Cushman, Kalmuss & Namerow (1993) interviewed 215 young women who placed infants through 30 maternity residences and agencies in 13 states — the largest contemporary US multistate birth-mother sample at time of publication. At 6 months post-placement, 38% reported "a lot of grief" and 27% "some grief," making the total experiencing significant grief 65%. We use the "a lot of grief" binary (38%) as the action-side rate because it most closely tracks persistent distress rather than transient sadness. The 6-month timeframe may underestimate lifetime rates: Madden et al. (2018) found satisfaction declined further over time, and the broader chronic-grief literature (Askren & Bloom 1999 review) identifies enduring grief in 40–50% of birth mothers across studies. The grief construct is a proxy for regret; grief and satisfaction are empirically distinct but correlated in this population.
  2. [2] Families in Society / Madden, Ryan, Aguiniga, Killian & Romanchik — The Relationship Between Time and Birth Mother Satisfaction With Relinquishment
    The Relationship Between Time and Birth Mother Satisfaction With Relinquishment
    Statistik
    Mean satisfaction with relinquishment score 3.11 on a 1–5 scale; satisfaction declined with time since placement (n=223 US birth mothers)
    Kutipan
    “"On a scale of 1 to 5, participants reported a mean satisfaction with relinquishment score of 3.11. Time since relinquishment, age of the respondent, education level, and income had a significant inverse relationship with birth mothers' satisfaction to place their child for adoption. The more time that has passed since the birth mothers placed their child, the less overall satisfaction some birth mothers felt." ”
    Data sumber dari
    2018-06-01
    Diakses
    2026-05-02
    Perhitungan
    Madden et al. (2018) surveyed 223 contemporary US birth mothers who placed an infant in the prior 25 years; n=223 is the anchor for the secondary source. The mean satisfaction score of 3.11/5 and its inverse relationship with time corroborate that the 38% acute grief rate from Cushman 1993 persists and may intensify long-term. This study does not publish a binary regret rate but confirms the direction. Two predictors of higher satisfaction — current contact with the adopted child and full-time employment — were present in only a subset of respondents, suggesting 38% is a conservative estimate for the broader birth-mother population.

Sumber: tidak bertindak

Buku besar klaim

Setiap angka di bawah ini adalah apa yang dilaporkan masing-masing sumber, dengan kutipan kata demi kata yang kami andalkan dan bagaimana kami sampai pada angka kami. Klik tautan mana saja untuk memverifikasi langsung.

  1. [1] PLOS ONE / Piotrowski — How many parents regret having children and how it is linked to their personality and health: Two studies with national samples in Poland
    How many parents regret having children and how it is linked to their personality and health: Two studies with national samples in Poland
    Statistik
    7–8% of parents in US and German population surveys reported regretting having children
    Kutipan
    “"On the basis of the surveys conducted in the US and in Germany, it was assumed that the percentage of parents regretting having a child could be around 7–8%." ”
    Data sumber dari
    2021-07-22
    Diakses
    2026-05-02
    Perhitungan
    Piotrowski (2021) synthesizes prior US and German survey evidence arriving at a 7–8% prevalence of parental regret in general population samples. This is an imperfect proxy for the inaction side: it measures regret among all parents, not among the specific subgroup who weighed relinquishment and chose to parent. No peer- reviewed study has measured regret among birth parents who considered and declined adoption. The Turnaway Study (Foster et al. 2020) is cited as a partial analogue — 4% of women denied abortion who carried to term expressed regret at 5 years — but those women sought abortions, not adoption placements. We use 0.08 (midpoint of the 7–8% range) as the primary inaction rate. The true rate for parents who specifically considered adoption before choosing to parent has not been measured; it may exceed 8% if their circumstances (ambivalence, resource constraints, social pressure) differ systematically from the general population.
  2. [2] ANSIRH / University of California, San Francisco — The Turnaway Study
    The Turnaway Study

    Lihat semua 2 entri Likelier yang mengutip sumber ini →

    Statistik
    By 5 years after being denied an abortion, 96% of women who carried to term indicated they were glad they had kept their pregnancies (4% regret)
    Kutipan
    “"By five years after being denied an abortion, 96% of women turned away indicated they were glad they had kept their pregnancies. One week after being turned away, 60% of the women expressed happiness over their pregnancies. Right after the baby was born, 88% of women no longer wished they had had an abortion." ”
    Data sumber dari
    2022-06-15
    Diakses
    2026-05-02
    Perhitungan
    The Turnaway Study followed ~1,000 women at 30 US facilities; the turnaway subgroup (~231 denied abortion) forms the relevant comparison. Only ~9% of turnaways pursued adoption; the majority parented. The 4% regret figure at 5 years is the lowest bound for the inaction side, but these women sought abortion — not adoption — so the comparator is imprecise. We cite Turnaway as a corroborating floor showing similarly low inaction regret and use the Piotrowski 7–8% as primary.

Catatan

Bukti pada kedua sisi sangat asimetris. Sisi tindakan (relinquishment) memiliki literatur khusus selama 40+ tahun, dengan dokumentasi konsisten kesedihan, kehilangan, dan kepuasan berkurang di berbagai negara dan desain studi. Sisi non-tindakan (mengasuh anak yang dipertimbangkan untuk dilepaskan) hampir tidak memiliki literatur khusus: tidak ada studi peer-review yang secara langsung mengukur penyesalan di antara wanita yang menimbang adopsi dan memilih untuk mengasuh sebagai gantinya. Tingkat non-tindakan 0,08 dipinjam dari survei penyesalan orang tua populasi umum (Piotrowski 2021), sebagian besar tidak pernah mempertimbangkan adopsi sama sekali. Tingkat sisi tindakan (0,38) adalah angka "banyak kesedihan" yang dilaporkan secara langsung dari Cushman, Kalmuss & Namerow (1993), sampel multistate AS dari 215 ibu kandung pada 6 bulan pasca-penempatan. Kesedihan adalah proksi untuk penyesalan, bukan penyesalan itu sendiri. Tiga pembauran struktural mendominasi perbandingan ini. Pertama, riwayat pemaksaan: banyak ibu kandung — terutama yang menempatkan sebelum 1990-an — melaporkan merasa tertekan dari keluarga atau agensi. Kedua, keterbukaan adopsi: adopsi terbuka kontemporer dengan kontak berkelanjutan menghasilkan hasil yang jauh lebih baik. Ketiga, studi longitudinal Namerow et al. tentang ibu remaja menemukan pengasuh melaporkan penyesalan lebih tinggi pada 4 tahun daripada orang yang melepaskan.

Data mentah: /api/decisions.json

Baru-baru ini dilihat di perangkat ini