In the IFIC 2025 Food and Health Survey, fielded in March 2025 among 3,000 US adults, 46% ranked pesticides and pesticide residues among their top-3 food safety concerns. That makes pesticides the third-highest food worry, after foodborne illness and cancer-causing chemicals. The 46% stands in for regret on the conventional side, because no US survey asks the question shoppers actually face: “do you regret not buying organic?”
The 46% measures ambient concern, not retrospective regret, and it counts many people who already buy organic and so cannot logically regret the conventional choice. Regret among conventional buyers is bounded above by 46% and is likely substantially lower. What the IFIC data does establish is a wide population of US adults with some unease about pesticide residues, whether or not it ever shaped what they buy.
Gallup’s 2014 national survey of 1,013 US adults found that 15% actively avoid organic foods. These are the people who have, in effect, decided the organic premium is not worth it as a regular purchase. That falls short of a regret measure too. Some of the 15% never paid an organic premium at all and avoid it on cost or principle, while others tried organic and walked back from it.
Put side by side, the two figures give an inaction-to-action ratio of about 3:1, and that ratio looks more precise than it is. The surveys are a decade apart, use different sampling and weighting, and measure different constructs: a behavioral stance in one case, a concern ranking in the other. Pew Research (2016) found that 55% of US adults believe organic produce is healthier than conventional. That supports the direction of the inaction signal and shares its flaw, since it also counts current organic buyers.
No survey has asked about regret over this decision directly, so the proxies bracket a direction without measuring it. More US adults carry organic-related concern than have committed to avoiding organic, which is the shape of inaction dominating in Gilovich’s sense. Whether residues on conventional US produce cause measurable harm at consumer exposure levels is a separate question. It is covered in the pesticide-residue-food entry, where the attributable lifetime risk is estimated at roughly 1 in 1,000,000. The regret data and the harm data do not converge. Concern is widespread, avoidance is narrower, and the measured residue risk on US-compliant produce is vanishingly small.








