Forty-three percent of US homeowners with an adjustable-rate mortgage reported regretting their choice in a December 2022 survey of 1,203 ARM holders conducted by PureSpectrum for U.S. News & World Report, the larger and earlier-fielded of the two ARM-regret surveys cited here. The primary driver, cited by 44% of regretters, was that their interest rate had adjusted to a higher level than they anticipated. A follow-up survey by Point in January 2024, drawing on 332 ARM holders, placed the regret rate at 70%, consistent with the pattern of escalating regret as further Federal Reserve rate increases pushed variable payments well above their initial levels. By contrast, no survey measures regret among fixed-rate holders as such: Bankrate’s 2025 general homeowner survey (n=1,363) did not separate borrowers by mortgage type, so the fixed-rate side has no direct measurement.
The evidence base is asymmetric. Both ARM surveys asked a direct regret question to ARM holders specifically; the fixed-rate side has no direct measurement. No published study has asked matched samples of ARM and fixed-rate borrowers the same regret question in the same instrument. What the surveys do show is that the ARM regret rate climbed from 43% to 70% between the two survey waves as the rate environment deteriorated. In the US context, the fixed-rate mortgage is taken here to be the dominant default (an assumption; no source listed gives the share), so choosing an ARM represents an active deviation from that default, a bet that rates would stay low.
The survey timing matters for interpretation. Both ARM surveys were fielded during or shortly after a historically rapid rate-tightening cycle (2022-2023), creating a period of maximum regret exposure. ARM regret in a falling-rate environment would likely be far lower, since resets would land at or below the initial rate rather than well above it. The 43% figure (the more conservative primary estimate) is a rate-cycle-specific snapshot, not a structural truth about the product. What is structural is the uncertainty asymmetry: fixed-rate borrowers know their payment in advance; ARM borrowers do not. That uncertainty is the proximate cause of regret in both surveys, not the product category per se.







