39% of parents who gave their child a smartphone before adolescence wish they hadn’t, according to a Harris Poll of 1,013 US parents conducted in February 2025 — the largest directly comparable action-side measure available for this decision. The figure is higher for social media access: 54% of parents who allowed it express the same regret. A separate global survey by HMD and Perspectus Global (July 2024, n=10,092 across five countries) found that more than half of the parents surveyed worldwide said they regret exposing their child to a smartphone at such a young age, and a third of respondents cited negative effects and personality changes as the key reasons. In the same Harris Poll, nearly a quarter of smartphone-giving parents say, with hindsight, they gave the device too young.
The Harris Poll figure carries an important framing caveat: the question asked whether parents wish they hadn’t given a phone “but felt they had to give in because so many of their children’s friends already had one.” This conflates retrospective regret with socially coerced compliance. Parents who gave a phone willingly and remain satisfied do not appear in the 39%, but neither do parents who regret the decision independently of peer pressure effects. The rate captures a specific subset — those experiencing regret-under-social-pressure — rather than all-cause regret. The true magnitude of unprompted parental regret about this decision is not known from existing surveys, though the HMD global figure (54%) using different question wording lands in the same order of magnitude.
What the data does not capture well is the distinction between regretting the device itself and regretting the access that came with it. Parents who gave a basic calling-only phone face different decisions than parents who gave full internet access, but surveys do not distinguish these categories. Sapien Labs’ Global Mind Project dataset (n=27,969, published May 2023) documents that mental wellbeing among 18-24-year-olds consistently improves with a later age of first smartphone or tablet ownership, with a steeper improvement for females than for males — though that is an outcome measure, not a parental-regret measure. Pew’s 2020 survey found that 73% of US parents already believed under-12 smartphone ownership was inappropriate before these outcome findings became widely publicized; the Harris Poll’s post-”Anxious Generation” 2025 data suggests that normative consensus on delayed provision has, if anything, strengthened.







