Bertindak vs. tidak bertindak: angka untuk tiap pilihan
Meninggalkan agama vs tetap beriman
Jika Anda bertindak
Meninggalkan agama
9,0%
Jika Anda tidak bertindak
Tetap dalam keyakinan
26%
Setidaknya satu angka adalah perkiraan tidak langsung, bukan tingkat penyesalan yang diukur. Cara setiap angka diperoleh dijelaskan di bawah.
Lifestyle
Terakhir ditinjau 2026-04-27
Kualitas bukti 4.25/5
Skor tinjauan delapan dimensi terhadap
rubrik kualitas
. Setiap dimensi dinilai 1–5.
D1 Verifikasi sumber
5/5
D2 Otoritas & independensi sumber
5/5
D3 Akurasi tingkat penyesalan
2/5
D4 Keterbandingan sumber
3/5
D5 Pola Gilovich
5/5
D6 Kualitas prosa
5/5
D7 Kelengkapan peringatan
5/5
D8 Kualitas sampel
4/5
Rata-rata4.25/5
Data tidak langsung: untuk keputusan ini, setidaknya satu angka berasal dari ukuran tidak langsung, seperti dampak, kepuasan, atau niat, atau dari perkiraan redaksi, bukan dari survei yang menanyakan penyesalan secara langsung. Catatan untuk tiap pilihan di bawah menjelaskan bagaimana angkanya diperoleh.
Jika Anda bertindak
Meninggalkan agama
9,0%
9% orang dewasa AS yang tidak berafiliasi secara religius mengatakan mereka mencari agama (proksi)
Orang dewasa AS yang tidak berafiliasi secara religius setelah meninggalkan agama masa kanak-kanak
lintas-bagian, 2023
Jika Anda tidak bertindak
Tetap dalam keyakinan
26%
26% Kristen yang mengidentifikasi diri melaporkan keraguan spiritual yang belum terselesaikan yang sedang berlangsung (proksi)
Orang dewasa AS yang mengidentifikasi diri sebagai Kristen
Angka untuk tiap pilihan (ukurannya disebut di halaman)
Meninggalkan agamaTetap dalam keyakinan
9,0%26%
Keputusan terkait
Keputusan yang serupa secara semantik — area yang sama, kompromi yang berbeda.
Barna Group found that 26% of self-identified Christians report ongoing
unresolved spiritual doubt — not past doubt they worked through, but current,
persistent questioning — the dominant inaction-side rate. On the action side,
PRRI’s 2024 report on religious change in America found that only 9% of
religiously unaffiliated US adults say the statement “I am looking for a
religion that would be right for me” describes them well, making active seeking
the closest available attitudinal proxy for action-side regret. Pew Research
Center’s December 2025 survey of 8,937 US adults adds context: among
those who kept their childhood religion, only 64% rated belief in its
teachings as extremely or very important, leaving a substantial minority
whose reasons for staying center on community, habit, or family rather
than conviction.
The 17-point gap favoring inaction regret aligns with Gilovich and
Medvec’s temporal framework, in which regrets of inaction tend to
compound over time. Identity decisions like religious affiliation fit
this pattern: leaving a religion is a concrete, time-stamped action
whose consequences become familiar, while staying despite doubt is an
ongoing omission that can accumulate as a “what if I had been braver”
narrative. Bleidorn et al.’s 2024 longitudinal study of roughly 20,000
Dutch adults found no significant change in life satisfaction after
deconversion, suggesting that the action itself is neither reliably
beneficial nor harmful to well-being. The size of the gap here likely
overstates true regret asymmetry because the two proxies measure
different intensities of dissatisfaction: actively seeking a new
religion is a higher bar than reporting unresolved doubt.
Both proxies stretch the meaning of “regret rate.” Seeking a religion
is not the same as regretting that one left; some seekers may want a
novel spiritual practice rather than a return to what they abandoned.
Ongoing doubt is not regret; many theologians treat doubt as intrinsic
to mature faith rather than a sign that staying was the wrong call.
Denomination-level variation is likely large, with high-demand groups
(LDS, Jehovah’s Witnesses) producing higher social costs for leaving
and thus potentially more seekers whose motivation is community re-entry
rather than spiritual conviction. The PRRI and Barna surveys differ in
date (2023 vs 2017) and population framing. All sources are US-centric;
in societies where religion is legally or socially compulsory, the
inaction/action frame barely applies.
Sumber: tindakan
Buku besar klaim
Setiap angka di bawah ini adalah apa yang dilaporkan masing-masing sumber, dengan kutipan kata demi kata yang kami andalkan dan bagaimana kami sampai pada angka kami. Klik tautan mana saja untuk memverifikasi langsung.
1/2 sumber diverifikasi secara independen kata demi kata terhadap sumber terkutip
[1]PRRI (Public Religion Research Institute) — Religious Change in America
Terverifikasi
Studi primer
Only 9% of religiously unaffiliated Americans say 'I am looking for a religion that would be right for me' describes them very or somewhat well
Kutipan
“"Only 9% of religiously unaffiliated Americans say the statement 'I am looking for a religion that would be right for me' currently describes them very or somewhat well."
”
Data sumber dari
2024-03-27
Diakses
2026-04-27
Verifikasi
Kutipan diambil ulang secara independen dan dikonfirmasi kata demi kata terhadap sumber terkutip selama audit pendasaran kami.
Perhitungan
PRRI surveyed US adults in 2023 as part of its American Values Atlas. Among the religiously unaffiliated — the majority of whom left a childhood religion — only 9% report actively seeking a new religious home. We treat this as an attitudinal proxy for action-side regret: wanting to return to religious affiliation implies dissatisfaction with the decision to leave. The 91% who are not looking suggest most leavers are content with disaffiliation. This is a proxy, not a direct regret measure: some of the 9% may be curious rather than regretful, and some who are not looking may still harbor private regret. regret_rate = 0.09.
[2]Journal of Personality (Wiley) — Psychological change before and after religious conversion and deconversion
Telaah sejawat
Neither converts nor deconverts showed significant changes in life satisfaction
Kutipan
“"Neither group showed changes in their well-being. … psychological well-being (self-esteem, life satisfaction, and depression)"
”
Data sumber dari
2024-02-01
Diakses
2026-04-27
Perhitungan
Bleidorn et al. (2024) used 11-wave longitudinal data from a nationally representative Dutch sample (N ~ 20,000) to assess changes before and after conversion/deconversion. The null finding on well-being supports the low action- regret rate: leaving religion does not systematically worsen life satisfaction, consistent with few leavers seeking to return. This source is Dutch, not American, limiting direct comparability but providing the best available longitudinal well-being data on deconversion.
Sumber: tidak bertindak
Buku besar klaim
Setiap angka di bawah ini adalah apa yang dilaporkan masing-masing sumber, dengan kutipan kata demi kata yang kami andalkan dan bagaimana kami sampai pada angka kami. Klik tautan mana saja untuk memverifikasi langsung.
1/2 sumber diverifikasi secara independen kata demi kata terhadap sumber terkutip
[1]Barna Group — Two-Thirds of Christians Face Doubt
Terverifikasi
Studi primer
26% of self-identified Christians still experience ongoing spiritual doubt
Kutipan
“"Just over one-quarter (26%) say they still experience spiritual doubt, while four in 10 (40%) say they have experienced it in the past but have worked through it."
”
Data sumber dari
2017-07-25
Diakses
2026-04-27
Verifikasi
Kutipan diambil ulang secara independen dan dikonfirmasi kata demi kata terhadap sumber terkutip selama audit pendasaran kami.
Perhitungan
Barna surveyed US adults who self-identify as Christian (or have in the past). Of those, 65% have questioned their beliefs at some point; 26% report ongoing unresolved doubt. We treat persistent unresolved doubt among those who stayed as an attitudinal proxy for inaction regret: it captures the fraction who remain affiliated but experience sustained questioning about the faith they chose to keep. This is a proxy, not a direct regret measure: many doubters view doubt as spiritually productive rather than as evidence they should have left. regret_rate = 0.26.
[2]Pew Research Center — Why Do Some Americans Leave Their Religion While Others Stay?
Studi primer
Among adults who kept their childhood faith, 64% cite belief in teachings as an extremely or very important reason for staying
Kutipan
“"most U.S. adults who still identify with their childhood religion credit the following as extremely or very important reasons: They believe the religion’s teachings (64% of adults who identify with their childhood religion say this). Their religion fulfills their spiritual needs (61%). Their religion gives their life meaning (56%)."
”
Data sumber dari
2025-12-15
Diakses
2026-04-27
Perhitungan
Pew surveyed 8,937 US adults (May 5-11, 2025). Among those who stayed in their childhood religion, 36% did not rate belief in teachings as extremely or very important. This complement provides context for the Barna doubt figure: a substantial minority stays despite tepid conviction. Used as contextual support for inaction_side, not as the primary regret_rate source.
Catatan
Tidak ada sisi yang memiliki survei penyesalan langsung; kedua tingkat adalah proksi sikap. Proksi sisi tindakan (9% mencari agama baru) menggabungkan keingintahuan dengan penyesalan — beberapa pencari mungkin menginginkan agama yang berbeda, bukan kembali ke yang mereka tinggalkan. Proksi sisi non-tindakan (26% keraguan yang sedang berlangsung) menggabungkan pertanyaan kognitif dengan penyesalan keputusan; banyak teolog memperlakukan keraguan sebagai intrinsik untuk iman yang matang. Kedua proksi menggunakan jenis konstruksi yang sama (laporan diri sikap tentang kepuasan agama saat ini), membuatnya lebih sebanding. Survei PRRI dan Barna berbeda dalam tanggal (2023 vs 2017) dan pembingkaian populasi. Studi longitudinal Bleidorn et al. adalah Belanda, bukan Amerika.