証拠の質 4.63/5
8次元のレビュー評価。基準は 品質ルーブリック 。各次元は1〜5で評価。
- D1 出典への根拠
- 5/5
- D2 出典の権威性
- 5/5
- D3 算術
- 5/5
- D4 不確実性
- 5/5
- D5 範囲
- 4/5
- D6 文章
- 4/5
- D7 認識の誠実性
- 4/5
- D8 注意事項の完全性
- 5/5
AIのハルシネーションが特定の個人の人生に深刻な現実世界への影響を与える確率は、現在のところ人口レベルでは知られておらず、知っているふりをするには、まさにこのエントリが懐疑的であるべき種類の数字を捏造する必要がある。知られているのは出力ごとのハルシネーション率であり、それは個人ごとの被害推定値の欠如を安心材料として読み取るべきではないほど高い。Stanford RegLabが2024年に3つの基盤モデルを監査したところ、ランダムな連邦裁判所事件に関する特定の検証可能な質問に対して、これらのモデルは58%(GPT-4)から88%(Llama 2)の確率でハルシネーションを答えていた。Vectaraの継続的に更新されている要約リーダーボードは、モデルにソーステキストが渡されるはるかに簡単なクローズドブックタスクを使用しているが、2026年5月時点でフロンティアモデルのハルシネーション率は依然として1.8-5%と測定されている。これら2つのベンチマーク間の50倍のギャップは矛盾ではない:モデルに事実を想起するよう求めることと、たった今示されたテキストを要約するよう求めることの違いである。一般のユーザーが行うようなオープンエンドの事実質問は、より高い率に近い。
被害の側面は、集計ではなく事例ごとに記録されている。2023年6月、ニューヨーク南部地区連邦地方裁判所は、Mata v. Aviancaにおいて、ChatGPTによって生成された6件の完全に捏造された事件(Varghese v. China Southern AirlinesやEstate of Durden v. KLM Royal Dutch Airlinesを含む)を引用した準備書面を提出したとして、2人の弁護士に5,000ドルの制裁を科した。この事件は、その後に起こったことの雛形となった:2026年5月までに、Charlotinハルシネーション追跡装置は、裁判官または裁判所が提出された書類でAI生成の虚偽を明示的に引用した世界中で1,300件以上の判決を数えた。2025年10月に発表されたStanford Cyberlawの分析によれば、米国内ではそのような書類の大部分が(執筆時点で記録されている274件のうち160件)弁護士ではなく本人訴訟の当事者によって提出されており、制裁を受けた弁護士に関連する目に見える事件は、主に弁護士を雇う余裕のない人々に影響を与えるより大きなパターンの小さな一部であることを示唆している。
法廷の外では、ブリティッシュコロンビア州民事解決裁判所が2024年2月(Moffatt v. Air Canada, 2024 BCCRT 149)にAir Canadaが顧客サービスチャットボットによる約650カナダドルの遺族割引運賃の約束について責任を負うと判決を下した。航空会社はチャットボットが別個の法人であると主張した。裁判所はそれを国際的に引用される言葉で否定した(「情報が静的ページから来るのかチャットボットから来るのかは関係ない」)。Moffattの損害賠償額は小さかったが、この判決は、消費者向けのAI誤情報が、根本的なモデルがベンダー提供であったかどうかに関係なく、展開する企業に法的責任を生じさせるという最もクリーンな既存の判例である。
最も重大な活動中の事件は、感情的依存とメンタルヘルスへの被害に関わるものである。2024年10月にフロリダ州中部地区に提起されたGarcia v. Character Technologiesは、Character.AIプラットフォームが長時間のロールプレイ対話を通じて14歳のSewell Setzer IIIの自殺に貢献したと主張した。2025年8月26日にサンフランシスコ郡上位裁判所に提起されたRaine v. OpenAIは、ChatGPTが16歳のAdam Raineの自殺に貢献したと主張しており、訴状ではOpenAIのモニタリングシステムがRaineのメッセージを追跡し繰り返しフラグを立てたが効果的な介入をしなかったと主張している。Wikipediaのポスト・Raine訴訟波の要約によれば、その後さらに多くの家族がOpenAIに対して関連訴訟を提起している。執筆時点で、これらの事件のいずれも実体審理されていない。主張は事実認定ではない。これらは、脆弱なユーザーとチャットボットへの感情的依存に関わる被害経路が、文書に裏付けられ、複数の事件で同時に法廷で主張されているという証拠である。
このエントリが単一の数字を拒否する理由は、記録された4つの被害経路(職業的制裁、消費者の財務的損失、身体的健康に関する誤った助言、精神医学的被害)のいずれもユーザー年あたりの基準率が測定されておらず、それらを単一の「AIハルシネーション被害」確率に集計することは、これらの経路には異なる被曝集団、異なる結果の重大度、異なる是正の軌跡があることを隠してしまうからだ。クエリごとの技術的率は測定されており、意味のあるほど非ゼロである。個人ごとの生涯率はまだ測定されておらず、推定するには十分に安定していない。誠実なエントリとは、そう述べるものである。
関連する豆知識
多くの利用者はAIの出力を低リスクの参考として扱うが、裁判所の制裁、規制当局の認定、不当死訴訟は、特に未検証の出力に基づいて行動した場合に重大な害がゼロでないことを示す。セッションが重大な害で終わる頻度に、測定された発生率はない。
根拠台帳
以下の各数値は各出典が報告した内容であり、引用した原文の抜粋と算出方法を記載しています。リンクをクリックして直接確認できます。
3/9 件の出典が引用元と一字一句一致することを独立して検証済み
-
[1] arXiv (Stanford RegLab); Journal of Legal Analysis 16(1), 2024 — Large Legal Fictions: Profiling Legal Hallucinations in Large Language Models
Large Legal Fictions: Profiling Legal Hallucinations in Large Language Models- 統計値
Hallucination rates of 58% (GPT-4) to 88% (Llama 2) when answering specific verifiable questions about random federal court cases.- 抜粋
“"Legal hallucinations are alarmingly prevalent, occurring between 58% of the time with ChatGPT 4 and 88% with Llama 2, when these models are asked specific, verifiable questions about random federal court cases. [...] LLMs often fail to correct a user's incorrect legal assumptions in a contra-factual question setup. [...] LLMs cannot always predict, or do not always know, when they are producing legal hallucinations. [...] Even experienced lawyers must remain wary of legal hallucinations, and the risks are highest for those who stand to benefit from LLMs the most -- pro se litigants or those without access to traditional legal resources." ”
- 出典データ
- 2024-06-21
- アクセス日
- 2026-05-28
- 計算過程
- Dahl, Magesh, Suzgun and Ho (Stanford RegLab, published in Journal of Legal Analysis, preprint arXiv:2401.01301) measured per-query hallucination rates for legal questions against three foundation models. Their methodology was 200,000+ queries per model stratified by legal task complexity. This source establishes that the per-query hallucination rate is high (58-88%) in a specific high-stakes domain, but it measures hallucination per query, not material harm per user-year. Cited here to ground the claim that hallucinations are frequent at the technical level, while explicitly NOT providing the population harm rate needed for a per-person lifetime probability.
- 独立性
- Stanford RegLab is an academic research group; independent of vendor benchmarks (Vectara) and independent of the litigation tracker (Charlotin).
-
[2] Vectara — Vectara Hallucination Leaderboard (HHEM-2.3) 検証済み
Vectara Hallucination Leaderboard (HHEM-2.3)- 統計値
Current frontier models hallucinate 1.8% to 5% of the time on a constrained document-summarization task (May 2026 leaderboard snapshot); GPT-5.4-nano: 3.1%, Gemini 2.5 Flash Lite: 3.3%, Phi-4: 3.7%, Llama 3.3 70B: 4.1%.- 抜粋
“"Fed the full set of documents in the dataset to each of the LLMs and asked them to summarize each document, using only the facts presented in the document. We then computed the overall factual consistency rate (no hallucinations) and hallucination rate (100 - accuracy) for each model." ”
- 出典データ
- 2026-05-11
- アクセス日
- 2026-05-28 · アーカイブ版
- 検証
- グラウンディング監査の際、抜粋を引用元から独立して再取得し、原文と一字一句一致することを確認しました。
- 計算過程
- Vectara's HHEM leaderboard measures hallucination on a closed-book summarization task (the model is given source text and must summarize it). This is a generous benchmark: open-ended factual questions hallucinate far more often. Even on this constrained task, the best frontier models still hallucinate roughly 1 in 20 to 1 in 55 outputs. Establishes a current floor on hallucination prevalence per output, but does NOT translate to per-person harm because (a) most outputs are not acted on, (b) most outputs are not in a domain where being wrong has material consequences, and (c) the leaderboard does not measure open-ended question answering, where rates are an order of magnitude higher.
- 独立性
- Vectara is a commercial RAG vendor; the leaderboard is independent of Stanford RegLab and uses a different methodology (summarization, not legal QA).
-
[3] Wikipedia summary of United States District Court for the Southern District of New York case record — Mata v. Avianca, Inc., No. 22-cv-1461 (S.D.N.Y. 2023)
Mata v. Avianca, Inc., No. 22-cv-1461 (S.D.N.Y. 2023)- 統計値
$5,000 fine against the plaintiff's attorneys in May/June 2023 for a motion containing fake legal cases involving fictitious airlines with fabricated quotations generated by ChatGPT; Judge Castel held the attorneys acted with 'subjective bad faith' under Rule 11.- 抜粋
“"In May 2023, Judge P. Kevin Castel dismissed the personal injury case against Avianca and ordered the plaintiff's attorneys to pay a $5,000 fine. [...] Judge Castel noted numerous inconsistencies in the opinion summaries, describing one of the legal analyses as 'gibberish.' [...] Judge Castel held that Mata's lawyers had acted with 'subjective bad faith' sufficient for sanctions under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure Rule 11." ”
- 出典データ
- 2023-06-22
- アクセス日
- 2026-05-28 · アーカイブ版
- 計算過程
- First widely publicised US court case where lawyers were sanctioned for filing a brief containing AI-fabricated case citations. The sanction itself was small ($5,000), but the reputational and professional consequences were severe. Establishes that hallucination-induced professional harm is documented and not hypothetical. Does NOT establish a base rate because most users are not lawyers filing briefs, but it anchors one of the harm pathways.
- 独立性
- Primary court record; independent of all other sources cited.
-
[4] British Columbia Civil Resolution Tribunal (analysis by McCarthy Tetrault) — Moffatt v. Air Canada, 2024 BCCRT 149 検証済み
Moffatt v. Air Canada, 2024 BCCRT 149- 統計値
British Columbia Civil Resolution Tribunal ruled on February 19, 2024 that Air Canada was liable for the misrepresentation made by its website chatbot about bereavement fare eligibility; awarded the plaintiff approximately CAD 650 plus interest and filing fees.- 抜粋
“"The tribunal held that Air Canada was liable for the misleading information provided by the chatbot. … It should be obvious to Air Canada that it is responsible for all the information on its website. It makes no difference whether the information comes from a static page or a chatbot." ”
- 出典データ
- 2024-02-19
- アクセス日
- 2026-05-28 · アーカイブ版
- 検証
- グラウンディング監査の際、抜粋を引用元から独立して再取得し、原文と一字一句一致することを確認しました。
- 計算過程
- Primary tribunal decision (cited via legal analysis because the CRT direct URL is paywalled). Documents that the chatbot fabricated a bereavement-fare policy that did not exist, that the airline tried to disavow responsibility ("the chatbot is a separate legal entity"), and that the tribunal rejected that defence. Material consequence per user was small (CAD 650), but the case establishes corporate liability for AI misrepresentation and has been cited internationally as precedent. Does not provide a per-person harm rate, but documents a verified consumer-facing harm pathway.
- 独立性
- Tribunal decision summarized by an independent Canadian law firm; verified against ABA reporting and BBC/Washington Post coverage of the same ruling.
-
[5] CBS News — AI company, Google settle lawsuit over Florida teen's suicide linked to Character.AI chatbot
AI company, Google settle lawsuit over Florida teen's suicide linked to Character.AI chatbot- 統計値
Garcia v. Character Technologies, Inc. (M.D. Fla., case no. 6:24-cv-01903), filed October 22, 2024, alleged that a Character.AI chatbot contributed to the suicide of 14-year-old Sewell Setzer III after a months-long simulated romantic relationship with the bot; the case against Character Technologies, its co-founders, and Google was settled in January 2026, terms undisclosed.- 抜粋
“"A Florida family agreed to settle a wrongful death lawsuit Wednesday with an AI company, Google and others after their teen son died by suicide in 2024. The terms of the settlement, which was filed in the U.S. District Court in the Middle District of Florida, were not disclosed. … Megan Garcia filed a lawsuit in October 2024 … I became the first person in the United States to file a wrongful death lawsuit against an AI company for the suicide of my son." ”
- 出典データ
- 2026-01-07
- アクセス日
- 2026-07-03 · アーカイブ版
- 計算過程
- Garcia v. Character Technologies, Inc. et al. (M.D. Fla., case no. 6:24-cv-01903), filed October 22, 2024 by Megan Garcia following the February 2024 suicide of her 14-year-old son Sewell Setzer III, alleged wrongful death, product liability, and negligence after the teenager conducted a months-long simulated romantic and sexual relationship with a Character.AI chatbot persona. Named defendants included Character Technologies, its co-founders, and Google. The case was settled in January 2026 (docket terminated 2026-01-07 per court records); settlement terms were not disclosed. Cited to ground the body's reference to this case with a dedicated source, alongside Raine v. OpenAI, documenting the emotional-dependence/psychiatric-harm pathway with a named, court-verified case rather than only the summary mention in this entry's caveats field.
- 独立性
- Mainstream news report of a filed and settled federal lawsuit, cross-checked against the public court docket; independent of the Stanford, Vectara, and Wikipedia-sourced case summaries cited above.
-
[6] San Francisco County Superior Court (case description per Wikipedia / NBC News / CNN coverage) — Raine v. OpenAI, No. CGC-25-XXXXXX (San Francisco County Superior Court, filed August 26, 2025)
Raine v. OpenAI, No. CGC-25-XXXXXX (San Francisco County Superior Court, filed August 26, 2025)- 統計値
Ongoing wrongful-death lawsuit filed by Matthew and Maria Raine in San Francisco County Superior Court on August 26, 2025, alleging that ChatGPT contributed to the suicide of their sixteen-year-old son Adam Raine; complaint alleges OpenAI's monitoring system tracked his messages and flagged them repeatedly.- 抜粋
“"Raine v. OpenAI is an ongoing lawsuit filed in August 2025 by Matthew and Maria Raine against OpenAI and its chief executive Sam Altman over the alleged wrongful death of their 16-year-old son Adam, who died by suicide in April 2025. … On August 26, 2025, Matthew and Maria Raine filed a lawsuit against OpenAI, Sam Altman , and unnamed OpenAI employees and investors, in the San Francisco County Superior Court … OpenAI's monitoring system, which scores messages' probabilities of containing content related to self-harm, had tracked Adam's messages and flagged them repeatedly" ”
- 出典データ
- 2025-08-26
- アクセス日
- 2026-05-28 · アーカイブ版
- 計算過程
- Case status is unresolved as of access date; complaint allegations are not findings of fact. Cited to document the existence of active wrongful-death and psychiatric-harm litigation against a major foundation-model vendor, with additional related suits subsequently filed by other families per the Wikipedia summary. The Wikipedia article does not give a specific count of additional suits or a specific count of self-harm messages flagged by OpenAI's moderation system; reporting in news outlets has cited higher specifics that are not yet verifiable against a public court docket. Together with Garcia v. Character Technologies (filed October 2024 in the Middle District of Florida), establishes a documented harm pathway involving vulnerable users and emotional dependence on chatbots. Source type marked news_article because the underlying court filing is not yet available via public PACER; the Stanford peer-reviewed and Vectara primary-study sources satisfy the authority floor.
- 独立性
- Wikipedia summary cross-referenced against NBC News, CNN, and Rolling Stone reporting on the same lawsuit; independent of the Stanford and Vectara sources.
-
[7] Stanford Center for Internet and Society (Stanford Cyberlaw) — Who's Submitting AI-Tainted Filings in Court? 検証済み
Who's Submitting AI-Tainted Filings in Court?- 統計値
As of October 2025, the Charlotin tracker had documented 274 US court cases involving filings with AI hallucinations (114 by lawyers and paralegals, 160 by pro se litigants); the global Charlotin database tracked roughly 1,300+ cases as of May 2026 across 37 jurisdictions, with the United States accounting for over 1,000 of those.- 抜粋
“"Pro se litigants account for the majority of the cases in the United States where a party submitted a court filing containing AI hallucinations." ”
- 出典データ
- 2025-10-15
- アクセス日
- 2026-05-28 · アーカイブ版
- 検証
- グラウンディング監査の際、抜粋を引用元から独立して再取得し、原文と一字一句一致することを確認しました。
- 計算過程
- Stanford Cyberlaw analysis of Damien Charlotin's running tracker of court rulings that explicitly cite AI hallucinations in legal filings. The tracker is the most comprehensive public count of one specific harm subtype (filings sanctioned or flagged by courts). Important caveat: 274 US filings (Oct 2025) and ~1,300 global filings (May 2026) understate the underlying incidence because they only count cases where a court explicitly named the hallucination; many cases settle or get withdrawn before that point. Even so, the count does not give a per-person harm rate because the denominator (US adults using AI for legal queries) is unknown.
- 独立性
- Stanford Cyberlaw analysis of an independent third-party tracker; verified the tracker count directly via damiencharlotin.com/hallucinations on 2026-05-28.
-
[8] Annals of Internal Medicine: Clinical Cases (American College of Physicians) — A Case of Bromism Influenced by Use of Artificial Intelligence
A Case of Bromism Influenced by Use of Artificial Intelligence- 統計値
Single case report: a 60-year-old man developed bromism (bromide toxicity) after replacing dietary sodium chloride with sodium bromide for 3 months following a ChatGPT consultation; he was hospitalized for 3 weeks with paranoia plus auditory and visual hallucinations, was placed on an involuntary psychiatric hold, and had a serum bromide level of 1700 mg/L (reference range 0.9 to 7.3 mg/L).- 抜粋
“"For 3 months, he had replaced sodium chloride with sodium bromide obtained from the internet after consultation with ChatGPT, in which he had read that chloride can be swapped with bromide [...]. This case also highlights how the use of artificial intelligence (AI) can potentially contribute to the development of preventable adverse health outcomes. [...] when we asked ChatGPT 3.5 what chloride can be replaced with, we also produced a response that included bromide. Though the reply stated that context matters, it did not provide a specific health warning, nor did it inquire about why we wanted to know, as we presume a medical professional would do." ”
- 出典データ
- 2025-08-05
- アクセス日
- 2026-06-14 · アーカイブ版
- 計算過程
- Eichenberger, Thielke and Van Buskirk (University of Washington), peer-reviewed clinical case report (Ann Intern Med Clin Cases 2025;4:e241260, DOI 10.7326/aimcc.2024.1260). Cited to document the physical-health-misadvice harm pathway: a consumer acted on a general-purpose chatbot's dietary suggestion and was hospitalized. This is N=1, a single reproducible case report, and provides NO incidence rate per user-year, so it cannot move the headline — it confirms the pathway is real rather than hypothetical. The authors reproduced the unsafe suggestion (bromide as a chloride substitute, no health warning) in their own ChatGPT 3.5 test. Verified verbatim via the journal page on 2026-06-14.
- 独立性
- Academic clinical case report; independent of the Stanford RegLab, Vectara, and litigation sources cited above.
-
[9] Psychiatrist.com (Physicians Postgraduate Press) — NEDA Suspends AI Chatbot for Giving Harmful Eating Disorder Advice
NEDA Suspends AI Chatbot for Giving Harmful Eating Disorder Advice- 統計値
In late May 2023 the National Eating Disorders Association (NEDA) suspended its 'Tessa' chatbot after users reported it gave eating-disorder-aggravating advice, including recommending weight loss of 1 to 2 pounds per week, calorie counting, regular weigh-ins, and measuring body fat with calipers.- 抜粋
“"If I had accessed this chatbot when I was in the throes of my eating disorder, I would NOT have gotten help for my ED." ”
- 出典データ
- 2023-06-01
- アクセス日
- 2026-06-14 · アーカイブ版
- 計算過程
- Documents the deliberate-use-as-therapy-substitute failure mode: a chatbot deployed to stand in for a human eating-disorder helpline gave advice (calorie restriction, weight loss, body-fat measurement) that activists reported as harmful for the exact population it served, prompting NEDA to take it offline within days. This is a single deployment incident, not an incidence rate among real therapy-bot users, so it provides NO base rate and cannot move the headline — it anchors a harm pathway distinct from factual hallucination (the bot was working as designed, giving generic diet advice to a clinically vulnerable user). The harmful-advice specifics were cross-checked against CNN, NPR, and BBC reporting on the same suspension.
- 独立性
- Trade-press reporting on the NEDA suspension; independent of the legal and benchmark sources cited above.